Anya Taylor-Joy reveals she chose The Witch over a Disney Channel pilot

Anya Taylor-Joy in The VVitch
(Image credit: A24)

Wouldst thou like to live deliciously? Anya Taylor-Joy has revealed that she chose A24 folk horror The Witch over a Disney pilot after being offered both on the same day.

"I remember it was the same day I got asked to be in a Disney Channel pilot, and it was so exciting to be offered anything at all that I ran around the house like a loon," she told Harpers Bazaar. "But I just had this really good feeling about The Witch that made me willing to forego the Disney experience for the thing that felt unknown to me, the thing that felt sacred." 

The Robert Eggers-directed horror would mark the first-ever film for Taylor-Joy, and would ultimately set her career in motion. Following its premiere at Sundance in 2015, the film was well-received and many were quick to praise her strong, and rather unnerving performance as an innocent young girl who ultimately gives in to evil temptations. Taylor-Joy did not reveal which Disney project she was offered.

 "I thought I’d done a really bad job, and I saw myself failing miserably with this dream I’d had for such a long time," she said of her performance, surprised by the critical acclaim. "I guess I’m not always the best judge of my own work."

She added, on The Witch: "It gave me the cornerstones of the way I work now, which is essentially the idea that there is no hierarchy on set: you work hard, you stay on top of the shots and you don’t assume anyone else is going to do that for you. Your title doesn’t stop at actor – you’re a creative on this film, and that’s how you need to approach it."

The Witch is currently streaming on Hulu, while Taylor-Joy later teamed up with Eggers for The Northman, released earlier this year. For more, check out our list of the best horror movies to stream right now.

Lauren Milici
Senior Writer, Tv & Film

Lauren Milici is a Senior Entertainment Writer for GamesRadar+ currently based in the Midwest. She previously reported on breaking news for The Independent's Indy100 and created TV and film listicles for Ranker. Her work has been published in Fandom, Nerdist, Paste Magazine, Vulture, PopSugar, Fangoria, and more.

Read more
Florence Pugh reveals why she "can't do" roles like Midsommar again: "I’ve been broken for a long while afterwards"
Furiosa
After Sigourney Weaver said she should be in Avatar, Anya Taylor-Joy says it's her "dream" to be Na'vi: "I watched that movie eight times in a row once"
Lily-Rose Depp in Nosferatu
Lily Rose Depp's "raw" and "intense" Nosferatu audition has been released online – and horror fans want her to get awards recognition
The Substance / Black Widow
Body horror meets Black Widow? The Substance director reportedly turned down the Marvel movie to focus on her award-winning horror
ayo edebiri
New horror movie from the studio behind Midsommar and Heretic unveils its first look and plot details
Ayo Edebiri in Opus
First trailer drops for The Bear star's new psychological horror movie with John Malkovich as a cult leader
Latest in Horror Movies
Cujo
Netflix is making a brand new adaptation of Cujo, the infamous Stephen King book about a killer dog
Drop
New horror movie starring White Lotus and Yellowstone actors gets a great Rotten Tomatoes score as early reactions call it the "perfect date night movie"
Clown in a Cornfield
First reactions to new clown horror movie say the slasher is giving Terrifier a run for its money
The House of the Dead first look 'Test Subjects'
Resident Evil director offers update on his horror movie adaptation of Until Dawn-sounding video game from over 20 years ago: "It's going to be very, very scary"
Emily Blunt in A Quiet Place Part 2
A Quiet Place 3 is finally happening, but it'll be a while because John Krasinski is so busy: "It's hard to get him"
Theo James as Hal in Osgood Perkins' The Monkey
It might only be March, but Stephen King adaptation The Monkey is now the highest grossing horror movie of 2025
Latest in News
inZOI Character Studio screenshot showing a young woman with short black/pink hair, black cat-like ears, and a black blouse with a bowtie
The creator of upcoming life sim Inzoi says he was "recklessly brave to even think about creating a game of this scale"
Rise of the Ronin
A year after its PS5 launch, Rise of the Ronin debuts on PC to "Mixed" reviews and performance complaints: "Stuttering on a 4090 is just... no"
Rise of the Ronin's photo mode offers some wonderful shots
On the heels of Rise of the Ronin's PC launch, its director says there's a "significant" amount of Japanese Switch gamers: "I am closely watching how this will change with the release of Switch 2"
Stardew Valley Castle Village mod
Stardew Valley Expanded creator is building an "even more ambitious" mod with a whole new city and "dungeons inspired by The Legend of Zelda"
Dino Crisis 2 art showing a young woman and man back-to-back amid tall green grass, both with their weapons drawn
Dino Crisis gets a fresh trademark filing by Capcom, but it might not mean the 26-year-old survival horror franchise will get a new installment like fans expect
Cujo
Netflix is making a brand new adaptation of Cujo, the infamous Stephen King book about a killer dog