BBFC: No proven connection between games and violence

27th Nov, 2007

In what may seem the worst tactical move since Hitler started eyeing up Russia, the British Board of Film Classificationhas admitted during Rockstar's appeal against Manhunt 2's continued ban in the UK that "there is insufficient evidence to prove, as a fact, there is a causal connection between violent games and behavioural harm". The fact itself is not news, but the admission at such a key time for the BBFC certainly is. So where does this leave the ban situation?

Well the hearing is over and a decision now has to be awaited. During its argument to the Video Appeals Commitee (The independent board which handles certification disputes in the UK), The BBFC did indeed drop the tack of games inciting violence but disclaimed that statement with the old chestnut that the research into the matter does not dis-prove it either. Quite possibly anillogical point when talking about banning something on an unproved assumption, but that's for the VAC to decide.

In addition to that, the BBFCfell back on its other main point in this debate, the fact that regardless of rating, Manhunt 2 will make it into the wrong, under-age hands at some point and thus has to be banned in order to err on the side of caution. It's true that we still have a major problem with uneducated parents not respecting game ratings, but whether the response to that should be to ban games rather than address an ineffective system is highly debatable.

Reference was also made to the question of whether games should be rated differently to movies, as the BBFC stated that film may be more involving as a medium but that it usually puts the consumer in the position of the victim rather than the killer, as is not the case in Manhunt 2.

No date is set for the VAC to announce its decision, but it has promised to make it as quickly as it can. The BBFC's own report on the link between games and violence (or not) can be foundhere.

David Houghton
Long-time GR+ writer Dave has been gaming with immense dedication ever since he failed dismally at some '80s arcade racer on a childhood day at the seaside (due to being too small to reach the controls without help). These days he's an enigmatic blend of beard-stroking narrative discussion and hard-hitting Psycho Crushers.
Latest in Action
Yasuke and Naoe ready to fight on the Assassin's Creed Shadows On The Radar thumbnail
On The Radar: Assassin's Creed Shadows coverage hub
Assassin's Creed Shadows Naoe assassinating target with Tanto skill
Assassin's Creed Shadows' first title update is a hotfix with three lines of patch notes and a download size up to 9GB
Assassin's Creed Shadows Nishinomiya Shrine
All Nishinomiya Shrine locations in Assassin's Creed Shadows
Assassin's Creed Shadows riddles Naoe answers
All Assassin's Creed Shadows riddle answers for NPC encounters
GTA 6 trailer screenshots showing lucia in an interview room
"GTA 6 is basically a huge meteor, and we will just stay clear of the blast zone": Publishers are in a frenzy over when to release their games to avoid Rockstar
Assassin's Creed Shadows
Assassin's Creed Shadows has been the series' best launch since Valhalla, but that was "a perfect storm we may never see again," says Ubisoft
Latest in News
Lunar Remastered Collection
"Will today’s players still enjoy a game from 30 years ago?": JRPG icon Kei Shigema says he was thrilled to see Lunar getting a remaster even if he's not involved himself
Nick Offerman as Bill and Murray Bartlett as Frank in The Last of Us episode 3
The Last of Us season 2 showrunners tease a "gorgeous" episode akin to season 1’s Emmy-nominated Bill and Frank story: "Just you wait"
The Witcher 4 screenshot with Ciri using sword and sorcery to fight an ancient monster
CD Projekt boss says "cutting-edge single-player games" – you know, like The Witcher 4 and Cyberpunk 2 – will "continue to enjoy great popularity" despite industry shifts
Cyberpunk 2077
Despite releasing exactly zero new games, CD Projekt bagged $120 million in profit for 2024 – the Witcher and Cyberpunk studio's third-best result ever
Muse
Daredevil: Born Again midseason trailer teases Matt Murdock’s violent fight with Muse, including a gory scene straight from the comics
Batman looking over the city during Batman: Arkham City, one of the best PS3 games.
The PS2 Batman Begins game was considered such a "disaster" that Christopher Nolan turned down a Dark Knight-inspired game