Captain America's shield has a secret, evil history ... and Bucky Barnes and Peggy Carter could be involved

Captain America: Sentinel of Liberty #2
Captain America: Sentinel of Liberty #2 art (Image credit: Marvel Comics)

Captain America: Sentinel of Liberty #2 ramps up the apparent conspiracy around Steve Rogers' legendary shield that was uncovered in the new series' debut issue, and as it turns out, some of Steve's oldest and closest allies including Bucky Barnes (AKA the Winter Soldier) and Peggy Carter may be in on the secret.

So what's the deal with Cap's allies, and is Steve's shield really "their symbol, not yours," as Steve was cryptically warned in the first issue? 

Captain America: Sentinel of Liberty #2 from writers Colin Kelly and Jackson Lanzing, artists Carmen Carnero and Nolan Woodard, and letterer Joe Caramagna opens in the wake of Cap's encounter in issue #1 with a new, apparently villainous version of the Destroyer, one of Steve Rogers' WWII allies.

(Image credit: Marvel Comics)

First, after writing a letter to Bucky who he hasn't seen since the preceding issue's events, Steve meets with two of his older WWII allies, Roger Aubrey, the former Destroyer whose identity was stolen by the villain in the previous issue, and Pam (likely Pam Hawley, a former ally and lover of Nick Fury), who have been decoding secret messages related to the unknown new villains who have been attacking Steve, including the new Destroyer.

Steve then discovers (thanks to his young new support staff) that the man who artistically designed the shield itself is named David Agboje, with the already known Myron MacLain actually building it. 

This is the first time David Agboje and his involvement with the creation of Cap's shield have been mentioned in the Marvel Universe, and it seems that even in continuity he's a mystery, as his records seem to have disappeared after designing Cap's shield.

(Image credit: Marvel Comics)

After a chance encounter with a boxing student Steve is teaching self-defense to that leads him to decode the villain group's next target - a massive renewable energy power plant in Germany known as 'the Forge' - Steve heads there to fight them off.

He discovers that the new villains are using technology from HYDRA, AIM, and The Hand, and may be known as 'the Tithed'. But before he can uncover more, the apparent leaders of the group - five mysterious villains known as the Love, the Money, the Revolution, the Machine, and the Power - appear in a massive ship bearing a version of the design of Steve's shield, launching a devastating and potentially deadly attack on the Super Soldier.

As he's blasted into the ground, he remembers the words "It's not your symbol, it's theirs."

As there are five points on a traditional star, there are five villains in the group that's taking on Steve. And there are apparently five points in another conspiratorial group including some of Steve's oldest friends and allies.

(Image credit: Marvel Comics)

While Steve takes on the Tithed, Bucky is revealed to be in Madripoor, punching his way into an exclusive card game. He confronts the dealer directly, who doesn't seem to appreciate Bucky blowing not just his own identity, but hers as well, as she's revealed to be Peggy Carter in disguise. 

Yes, the same Peggy Carter who fought at Steve’s side in WWII. She’s been alive and well in the current Marvel Universe for a few years now.

In Sentinel of Liberty #1, Bucky crossed someone off a board of five people connected by strings in the shape of a star (insert your Charlie Day meme here), saying "one down, four to go." Along with Bucky himself, he reveals that Peggy is one of these five conspirators - though it remains to be seen exactly who all five are, what they're hiding, and how it connects to the new villains who seem to be known as 'the Tithed.'

Captain America: Sentinel of Liberty #3 goes on sale August 10, while Captain America: Sentinel of Liberty #4 has been promised to reveal more of the code that's being used by the Tithed.

Get the answers to all your questions about the origins and history of Captain America's shield.

George Marston

I've been Newsarama's resident Marvel Comics expert and general comic book historian since 2011. I've also been the on-site reporter at most major comic conventions such as Comic-Con International: San Diego, New York Comic Con, and C2E2. Outside of comic journalism, I am the artist of many weird pictures, and the guitarist of many heavy riffs. (They/Them)

Read more
cover of Captain America #300
10 Best Captain America villains of all time
Danny Ramirez and Anthony Mackie in Captain America: Brave New World
Captain America: Brave New World ending explained – Who dies in the Marvel movie? How does it set up the next Avengers?
Captain America: Brave New World
That Captain America: Brave New World cameo changed several times, but it was always going to be that character
CAPTAIN AMERICA & VOLSTAGG #1
Steve Rogers gets his own Asgardian armor in this preview of his team up with Volstagg of the Warriors Three
Captain America #14 cover excerpt
Best Captain America comics of all time
Jaoquin Torres as played by Danny Ramirez
Who is Joaquin Torres in Captain America: Brave New World? The weird-but-true comic book origins of the new Falcon
Latest in Marvel Comics
Daredevil: Born Again
Marvel may have just sneakily confirmed one of the biggest Daredevil: Born Again fan theories
New Champions #4
Meet Gold Tiger, the young Wakandan hero whose origin will be revealed in New Champions #4
Marvel Rivals: Ignite #1
Marvel Rivals goes manga in a new comic from Peach Momoko and three other Japanese artists that reveals several new in-game costumes
Fantastic Four #30
Thanks to Doctor Doom, Ben Grimm is no longer the Thing and his kids don't even recognize him in Fantastic Four #30
Silver Surfer sitting on his board
Marvel June 2025 solicitations: 10 must-have comics to pre-order this month
Spider-Man swings into action alongside the Fantastic Four and Ms. Marvel.
Spider-Man and the Fantastic Four team up in a new story from Jay and Silent Bob creator Kevin Smith
Latest in News
Batman looking over the city during Batman: Arkham City, one of the best PS3 games.
The PS2 Batman Begins game was considered such a "disaster" that Christopher Nolan turned down a Dark Knight-inspired game
Assassin's Creed Shadows Naoe assassinating target with Tanto skill
Assassin's Creed Shadows' first title update is a hotfix with three lines of patch notes and a download size up to 9GB
a victory screen showing someone in a day of the dead mask and another who is an old man looking sad
GeoGuessr is coming to Steam and you can go head-to-head to prove you're the best geographer of them all
Vampire The Masquerade Bloodlines 2
Vampire: The Masquerade – Bloodlines 2 "is done," but it's been delayed again to October for "bug fixing, stability, and performance"
Ben Affleck in Air
Ben Affleck isn't in The Odyssey, but he plans to visit the set anyway to watch Christopher Nolan work: "He's one of the greatest filmmaking architects to ever live"
GTA 6 trailer screenshots showing lucia in an interview room
"GTA 6 is basically a huge meteor, and we will just stay clear of the blast zone": Publishers are in a frenzy over when to release their games to avoid Rockstar