A Dark Souls bet turned so sour it ended up in TV court

Sometimes games bets get serious. Possibly a little too serious when the fiendish Dark Souls is involved and this one ended up on ITV court room show Judge Rinder. Here's Thomas.

The reason Thomas looks so awkward is because he foolishly got somewhat inebriated at the Glastonbury music festival and bet his friend Michael and brother David that he would complete Dark Souls in the year before the next Glastonbury. He apparently even said, in his pie-eyed state, that it would be "very easy."

This is Michael and David.

The reason they look so sheepish is because they brought Thomas to a real life (fake) court to ask for the £100 he owes them for not in fact completing Dark Souls on the hardest difficulty in a year. Below is Judge Rinder. He's the UK's answer to Judge Judy and he's not impressed.

Evidence brought to the court? A printed contract that was drawn up by the brothers to make sure that Thomas knew he was meant to be completing the game, despite his protestations that he couldn't remember the conversation in the first place. One major flaw was that this was not signed by Thomas and appeared to have been created in something similar to Microsoft Paint. Thomas' defence was that he'd gone to uni and, I quote, "a degree is easier than Dark Souls." He's probably right.

Judge Rinder was suitably disparaging about the affair, hiding his head in his hands and despairing that he "used to do international law" as the duo explained why they'd suggested that Thomas complete the game as the Deprived class. If you remember that means you're dressed in only a loincloth.

While it's probably not the best representation the gaming community could ever have with Rinder unable to hide his comedy contempt, it's a lesson in what happens when you decide to make ridiculous claims about Dark Souls. You end up in fake court, with your fake friends and the case gets dismissed for being utterly ludicrous. You can catch up with the full episode on ITV's catch up service here.

Seen something newsworthy? Tell us!

Louise Blain

Louise Blain is a journalist and broadcaster specialising in gaming, technology, and entertainment. She is the presenter of BBC Radio 3’s monthly Sound of Gaming show and has a weekly consumer tech slot on BBC Radio Scotland. She can also be found on BBC Radio 4, BBC Five Live, Netflix UK's YouTube Channel, and on The Evolution of Horror podcast. As well as her work on GamesRadar, Louise writes for NME, T3, and TechRadar. When she’s not working, you can probably find her watching horror movies or playing an Assassin’s Creed game and getting distracted by Photo Mode. 

Latest in Dark Souls
Dark Souls: Remastered
Dark Souls Remastered seamless co-op is officially coming from the creator behind the same Elden Ring mod, and it's set to include everything from PvP to scaling
Love Nikki character wearing Dark Souls 3 helmet
There's a whole world of Dark Souls-style lore hidden in this series of dress-up games, and I bet you can't tell which is which
Elden Ring screenshot showing Ranni, a young woman with pale ice-y blue skin and a large brimmed witch-like hat
The Elden Ring anime made entirely by fans of the RPG is almost here, and even Let Me Solo Her can't wait: "They're honestly cooking up something amazing"
One of Elden Ring's best mods comes to Dark Souls 3 as a prolific FromSoftware modder gets seamless co-op up and running
Elden Ring screenshot showing Ranni, a young woman with pale ice-y blue skin and a large brimmed witch-like hat
Elden Ring and Dark Souls dataminer "overwhelmed" as community clubs together to cover "a looming $15,000 in medical expenses" in a single afternoon
Dark Souls 3
After almost 2 years of attempts, Dark Souls legend completes his brutal 7-game "God Run 3": Demon's Souls to Elden Ring without taking a single hit, all at level 1
Latest in News
A screenshot shows Pokemon Legends: Z-A protagonists standing in a city at night.
Pokemon is a stealth game now: Pokemon Legends Z-A wants you to sneak attack trainers during its nighttime battle royale
Samus firing a beam in a screenshot from Metroid Prime 4: Beyond.
Our best look at Metroid Prime 4 yet shows Samus with a new suit and some psychic abilities, but we're still staring down a 2025 placeholder
a cyborg pac-man fused with a mysterious protagonist grabs an enemy off a ledge and eats it
Pac-Man the gritty Metroidvania, inexplicably in the works at Amazon's Secret Level, gets a new launch date and some very dark gameplay
A screenshot from Witchbrook.
Gorgeous pixel art life sim Witchbrook blends Stardew Valley and Hogwarts Legacy, as the wizard school RPG arrives later this year
Nintendo shows off the Switch and Switch 2's Virtual Game Cards system with two Miis
Preparing for the Switch 2, Nintendo announces "Virtual Game Cards" you can move between consoles and loan to friends for up to 2 weeks
Nintendo Switch 2 controller slot
Best Buy just confirmed the Nintendo Switch 2 pre-order date, and there's only days left to wait