Dragon Age narrative lead says BioWare tried AI for content generation and it came out "soulless"

Mass Effect 2
(Image credit: BioWare)

BioWare once tried their hand at procedural generator for scripts, and the result "soulless."

Former BioWare narrative lead David Gaider recently took to Twitter to respond to a Guardian article talking up the possibility of AI writing scripts for game developers. Gaider reflected on the time BioWare tried their hand at "procedural content generation," and revealed the result was less than satisfactory.

Gaider writes that while the AI gave BioWare countless RPG-style quests, none of them were better than your standard "bring me 20 beetle heads." That, entirely understandably, is not what BioWare was going for in their approach to quest design in games like Mass Effect and Dragon Age.

The BioWare veteran goes on to say that developers shouldn't want anything more than this from AI writing. Developers will unfortunately think they can get more from an AI than your standard dull questline, Gaider concludes, but they will absolutely be mistaken in thinking this.

When we think about BioWare greats like Dragon Age and Mass Effect, we think about them for their branching narratives and memorable characters. Gaider, and no doubt other BioWare staffers, know AI just can't deliver on this, and can't give that player what they truly want: standout storytelling moments.

Gaider's next adventure is Stray Gods, a musical roleplaying game where Greek Gods intersect with mere humans. We haven't seen anything of gameplay for Stray Gods yet, but we know it'll feature narrative-shifting choices, and music from Journey and The Banner Saga composer Austin Wintory.

Check out our new games 2023 guide for a look at all the games you can play while you wait for Stray Gods to arrive.

TOPICS
Hirun Cryer

Hirun Cryer is a freelance reporter and writer with Gamesradar+ based out of U.K. After earning a degree in American History specializing in journalism, cinema, literature, and history, he stepped into the games writing world, with a focus on shooters, indie games, and RPGs, and has since been the recipient of the MCV 30 Under 30 award for 2021. In his spare time he freelances with other outlets around the industry, practices Japanese, and enjoys contemporary manga and anime.

Read more
Dragon Age: The Veilguard reveal trailer screenshot showing Lace Harding, a dwarven woman with long red hair and a freckled face
Legendary Dragon Age writer looks to Baldur's Gate 3 devs while giving EA advice after The Veilguard: "Follow Larian's lead and double down on that"
Dragon Age: The Veilguard
After misses like Mass Effect: Andromeda and Anthem, Dragon Age: The Veilguard creative director says BioWare decided to "look at what's worked in the past" for inspiration
Mio and Zoe holding a dragon during the trailer for Split Fiction.
Split Fiction's Josef Fares thinks game devs should embrace AI: "I can understand the fact that some people could lose their jobs, but that goes for every new technology"
Dragon Age: The Veilguard
Dragon Age: The Veilguard creative director on Mass Effect 2 comparisons and how the RPG draws from BioWare's past successes: "don't reinvent the wheel if you don't have to"
Dragon Age: The Veilguard
Baldur's Gate 3 dev slams EA's BioWare layoffs as "a short-term cost-saving measure" that "doesn't solve a long-term problem"
Dragon Age: The Veilguard screenshot showing Solas, a pale bald Elven mage, wielding lightning-like powers while grimacing
As EA hints The Veilguard's low sales could be due to a lack of live service elements, former Dragon Age lead calls out "silly" demands to "fundamentally change the DNA of what people loved"
Latest in Action Rpg
Monster Hunter Wilds
Capcom promises "this is just the start for the next generation of Monster Hunter" as Wilds shatters sales milestones: "The Guild authorizes this celebration!"
Monster Hunter Wilds screenshot of spider boss Nerscylla
Monster Hunter Wilds takes an infamously rare and annoying material from the old games and absolutely buries you in it – and also buries you in tiny spiders
Monster Hunter Wilds
Playing Monster Hunter Wilds in multiplayer is a confusing mess, but in defiance of Capcom I've jury-rigged a co-op campaign that actually works
Monster Hunter Wilds Ember Rufflizard
Monster Hunter Wilds Ember Rufflizard location
A Monster Hunter Wilds character holding binoculars.
Capcom asks Monster Hunter Wilds players how they feel about the game in a survey longer than most hunts, and I guess y'all had feedback because it crashed due to "heavy traffic"
Monster Hunter Wilds Whoppers
How to catch a Monster Hunter Wilds Whopper
Latest in News
Dragon Age Inquisition
Dragon Age actor says the last time he played Inquisition, he upheld the RPG tradition led by Baldur's Gate 3 actors and romanced his own character: "Which is the best — the best"
Monster Hunter Wilds
Capcom promises "this is just the start for the next generation of Monster Hunter" as Wilds shatters sales milestones: "The Guild authorizes this celebration!"
Lester sitting at a computer in some artwork for GTA Online
Some GTA 5 players can't bring their characters to the new PC upgrade, and the open-world game's mixed Steam reviews are hammering FPS caps and a lack of text chat
Kamala Khan holds Jean Grey's body in an homage to the cover of Uncanny X-Men #136
45 years after the original Dark Phoenix Saga, Ms. Marvel Kamala Khan will travel back in time to save X-Men history
Assassin's Creed Shadows screenshot showing Yasuke kneeling and praying while wearing a traditional purple robe
Assassin's Creed Shadows is the first game in the series with "a fully customizable sandbox" as your base, which is where Yasuke and Naoe hang out and pet baby animals
Monster Hunter Wilds screenshot of spider boss Nerscylla
Monster Hunter Wilds takes an infamously rare and annoying material from the old games and absolutely buries you in it – and also buries you in tiny spiders