The Boys star's new horror movie gets great first reactions calling it "truly terrifying" featuring some of the "best performances" of 2025 so far

The Surrender
(Image credit: SXSW)

Julia Max's feature film debut The Surrender, starring The Boys star Colby Minifie, is getting very positive early reactions following its world premiere at SXSW. Critics are calling it a "truly terrifying" horror movie with "formidable" lead performances and some "edge-of-your-seat" sequences.

Co-starring Grey's Anatomy star Kate Burton, the film explores the complicated relationship between a mother and her daughter as they are forced to confront their differences in order to survive a supernatural threat of their own making.

"Despite the odds, it does [sustain its high-wire act], delivering a Final Girl movie with a metaphysical twist. If Charlie Kaufman scripted Sam Raimi’s Drag Me to Hell, it would look something like this," reads Variety's review.

"The Surrender’s big scare set piece rattled me to my core because I cared and fully understood what landed them there. It’s well crafted and well earned. A true edge-of-your-seat sequence while watching, and one I’ve yet to shake well after," wrote journalist Perri Nemiroff on X.

"It’s a wholly unique vision of grief, filled with carnage and unspeakable horror that escalates at a steady clip. To see it interpreted in this way, a visceral, thrilling and high-stakes vision without ever dampening the complicated, messy, and unglamorous nature of loss, marks Max as one to watch," said Bloody Disgusting, calling Colby Minifie a "formidable lead."

Minifie is best known for playing Ashley Barrett in The Boys and its spin-off Gen V. She also played Virginia in seasons 5 and 6 of Fear the Walking Dead, and had a small role in Netflix's critically-acclaimed movie I'm Thinking of Ending Things.

The Surrender is yet to announce a release date. The official synopsis fo the film reads: "A fraught mother-daughter relationship is put to a terrifying test when the family patriarch dies and the grieving mother hires a mysterious stranger to bring her husband back from the dead. As the bizarre and brutal resurrection spirals out of control, both women must confront their differences as they fight for their lives, and for each other."

In the meantime, you can check our list for all upcoming horror movies in 2025 and beyond, and our list of best horror movies of all time.

Mireia Mullor
Contributing Writer

Mireia is a UK-based culture journalist and critic. She previously worked as Deputy Movies Editor at Digital Spy, and her work as a freelance writer has appeared in WeLoveCinema and Spanish magazines Fotogramas, Esquire, and Elle. She is also a published author, having written a book about Studio Ghibli's 'Kiki's Delivery Service' in 2023. Talking about anime and musicals is the best way to grab her attention.

You must confirm your public display name before commenting

Please logout and then login again, you will then be prompted to enter your display name.

Read more
Jack Quaid and Sophie Thatcher in Companion
First reactions for The Boys and Yellowjackets stars' new horror movie are calling it "absolutely bonkers" and "genuinely brilliant"
Ayo Edebiri in Opus
The Bear star's new A24 cult thriller proves Ayo Edebiri needs to be the final girl in a horror movie
Sophie Thatcher and Jack Quaid in 'Companion'
Director of new twisty romance horror Companion explains why it wouldn't have worked without The Boys and Yellowjackets stars: "I can't imagine anyone else"
Drop
New horror movie starring White Lotus and Yellowstone actors gets a great Rotten Tomatoes score as early reactions call it the "perfect date night movie"
Companion trailer
The Boys star's new sci-fi horror from the creators of Barbarian gets an intriguing first trailer that reveals a big twist
Still from upcoming horror movie The Woman in the Yard
Blumhouse horror movie The Woman in the Yard's new trailer has genre fans trying to predict its twist – and some of their theories sound pretty plausible
Latest in Horror Movies
The Surrender
The Boys star's new horror movie gets great first reactions calling it "truly terrifying" featuring some of the "best performances" of 2025 so far
Cloverfield monster
Cloverfield 2 is still moving forward as director teases the long-awaited sequel: "You're gonna get something amazing"
Jenna Ortega as Astrid Deetz in Beetlejuice Beetlejuice
Beetlejuice 2 star Jenna Ortega would love to star in another classic horror comedy franchise: Gremlins
Lea Myren as Elvira in The Ugly Stepsister
Cinderella body horror movie that made viewers sick gets release date, and it’s coming very soon
Indy in Ben Leonberg's haunted house horror Good Boy
Good Boy, a new scary movie told from a dog's POV, is being called "one of the best horror films of the year"
Cujo
Netflix is making a brand new adaptation of Cujo, the infamous Stephen King book about a killer dog
Latest in News
The Surrender
The Boys star's new horror movie gets great first reactions calling it "truly terrifying" featuring some of the "best performances" of 2025 so far
Ender Magnolia screenshot showing a spirit shooting at a monster enemy
One of the best new Metroidvanias just got a huge update with New Game+ and heaps more content like a boss rush mode
Deep Rock Galactic
Deep Rock Galactic roguelike dev says innovation for innovation's sake is too expensive to survive: "We're a studio of 50 people with bills to pay"
Assassin's Creed Shadows Naoe assassinating target with Tanto skill
Assassin's Creed Shadows' expert difficulty looks like the best way to play since it does way more than just dial up enemy HP bars
WandaVision
Marvel star Elizabeth Olsen says she's enjoyed playing Scarlet Witch for over 10 years and would "love to keep doing more"
Cloverfield monster
Cloverfield 2 is still moving forward as director teases the long-awaited sequel: "You're gonna get something amazing"