Marvel fans have a theory about the formation of the Thunderbolts – and Valentina's motives

Thunderbolts* trailer
(Image credit: Marvel Studios)

Sam Wilson has only just touched down in Captain America: Brave New World, but already fans are predicting what's in store with them when they run into the Thunderbolts later this year. The new film starring Florence Pugh, David Harbour, Wyatt Russell, and Sebastian Stan will see them unite in a ragtag team of heroes against Valentina Allegra De Fontaine, played by Julia Louis-Dreyfus. It's this joint aim that one fan thinks they've figured out and would explain why in the latest preview, Pugh's Yelena tells Valentina to kindly eat shit.

The fan over on Reddit hypothesized that the rough and ready-enhanced individuals who are all surprised to see each other at an unnamed test facility do so as a trial run for the meek and mild Lewis Pullman's Bob (who is really The Sentry). Val is hoping that The Sentry will be an Avengers alternative, and Yelena and company are wandering in as lambs to the slaughter. They somehow make it out alive, and all join up to get back at the woman who wronged them all.

"What Val doesn't account for, is that the team actually work together somehow and escapes, taking Sentry/Bob with them not knowing his importance, and then the chaos of the film ensues and Sentry, now released, becomes Void," the fan guesses. "The Thunderbolts feel an element of guilt for their part in releasing Sentry, and Bucky then comes and asks the team to help defeat him, proving Val wrong about what this team is capable of."

Another fan backed the claim saying, "Yeah, I think you're actually spot on. Feels like an unintentional misdirected where everybody is assuming the Thunderbolts are a team assembled by Val when the actual trailers don't indicate that at all. Most of them work for Val but not under a team. Sentry is actually the Avengers replacement that Val has in mind."

The theory certainly gives a Dirty Dozen, do-or-die vibe to what feels fitting of what's on show so far. You can see how they handle themselves when Thunderbolts strikes in theatres on May 2, 2025. Get the full lowdown on the titular team with our guide here.

Nick Staniforth
Contributing Writer

Nick is a freelancer whose work can be found at Screen Rant, The Digital Fix, and Looper. He loves movies, TV, DC, and Marvel. He also believes that the best Robin Hood is still a talking fox.

Read more
Thunderbolts* trailer
The latest Thunderbolts trailer all but confirms a major Marvel fan theory that one character is a goner
Thunderbolts
The big Thunderbolts theory about Taskmaster may not be so straightforward
Thunderbolts
Sebastian Stan teases Marvel's Thunderbolts as he compares it to an iconic '80s teen movie
Thunderbolts
New Thunderbolts trailer sees the MCU's most beloved antiheroes step in for the Avengers and save the world
The cast of Thunderbolts
Marvel fans are revealing who they'd like to see added to the Thunderbolts lineup, from Moon Knight to a major Hulk villain
Thunderbolts
Thunderbolts release date, cast, trailer, plot, and more about the Marvel movie
Latest in Marvel Movies
Avengers: Doomsday directors admit it's a "difficult" movie to make but tease some great Marvel collaborators "old and new"
Robert Downey Jr. as Doctor Doom
The Russo Brothers say Robert Downey Jr. "tried to talk us into" doing another Avengers movie but they "said no" until they heard the pitch for Doomsday: "That story has to be told"
Amanda Seyfried in Mamma Mia!
Mean Girls star Amanda Seyfried was offered the role of Gamora in the MCU, but turned it down because she thought Guardians of the Galaxy would be "Marvel's first bomb"
Robert Downey Jr. during the Doctor Doom announcement at Marvel's SDCC 2024 panel
Kevin Feige was behind the decision to bring Robert Downey Jr. in as Doctor Doom, and the conversation was had "a while ago"
Ryan Reynolds in Deadpool
Ryan Reynolds has given us the weirdest Marvel movie marathon ever to mark 10 years since the first Deadpool movie started filming
Pacific Rim
The 35 greatest 2010s sci-fi movies
Latest in News
Adam Scott as Mark S and Britt Lower as Helly R in Severance season 2
There might have been another reason for Mark's decision in the Severance season 2 finale
Silent Hill f art showing a person covered in plants
Silent Hill f has been pre-emptively banned in Australia, with no reason given for the 'refused classification' rating
Assassin's Creed Shadows review gameplay showing Yasuke overlooking the sea and lush green scenery
Assassin's Creed Shadows has already "surpassed the launches of AC Origins and Odyssey" with 2 million players and counting
Helldivers 2 screenshot showing someone using a big gun
Helldivers 2 boss says "death and rebirth" is a natural part of the games industry, but it's "unnecessarily brutal" right now "because we don't diversify enough"
A Dragon Age character stares out against a blue background.
BioWare makes a return to Dragon Age: The Veilguard with a surprise PC update, months after layoffs and a seemingly final patch
God of War 3
God of War PSP's seamless loading was only possible because a Jak & Daxter game was also running in the background