Marvel fans have come up with a wild theory that could soften the blow of Agatha All Along episode 5: "Glad to see we're all going straight to delusion"

Patti LuPone as Lilia Calderu in Agatha All Along
(Image credit: Marvel Studios)

Warning! This article contains major spoilers for Agatha All Along episode 5. If you've yet to tune in 

Oh boy, Agatha All Along's latest installment was a lot, huh? Episode 5, titled 'Darkest Hour, Wake Thy Power' saw Agatha's coven face another trial on the Witches Road', which dramatically culminated in the death of another member and the reveal that 'Teen' is actually Billy, Wanda Maximoff's son. 

In an attempt to ease the pain, though, Marvel fans have come up with a convincing theory which, if true, could mean that none of it actually happened – and it involves Patti LuPone's sorceress Lilia Calderu and her future-telling skills...

"Even if we ignore how strange the end of the episode was, everything was incredibly weird that whole time," explained one user on Twitter. "Everyone was treating Teen differently, the door was plain wood, Lilia pulled away from the board, they turned on Agatha SO easily. This has to be one of Lilia's visions."

"Glad to see we're all going straight to delusion, convincing ourselves that this trial was either manipulated by Teen or it's Lilia's vision instead of acknowledging the fact that the writers perhaps fumbled the ball REALLY HARD," said another.

"I really think Teen created everything, or that it's one of a Lilia's vision. That's right, I'm in denial," tweeted a third, while a fourth cried: "I'm trying to convince myself this was just a vision Lilia is having and my girl Alice is not really dead, because the alternative hurts too much."

One viewer even went on to suggest that Lilia has been experiencing flashforwards since earlier on in the show, randomly mumbling stuff like, "Alice, don't" and "Try to save Agatha" out of context.

While it may seem like a wild theory, the thought of episode 5 being a premonition of Lilia's isn't too far of a stretch when you comb over it, and realize that there are a few nods to suggest that's what's happening.

Firstly, 'Darkest Hour, Wake Thy Power' starts with Lilia waking up from a vision of the Salem Seven closing in on the coven, and sure enough to sinister septet show up shortly after. A little later, when the gang figure out that they're going to have to commune with the dead in the Road's newest challenge, Lilia notes to Teen: "I read people, I read time."

When the group are plagued by a horrible sound, she shouts, "I hated this the first time!" and in another scene, she responds to Alice's impulsive decision to cast a protection spell over a possessed Agatha with another seemingly random statement: "Knight of Wands". In tarot, 'Knight of Wands' can signal a good start or be an indication that things are going better than you expected. When Agatha starts (unknowingly?) absorbing Alice's power, killing her, Lilia is the first and loudest to protest. Might that be because she knows what them failing with ultimately lead to already? And if so, will she able to intervene before it's too late? We'll have to wait until next week to see...

Agatha All Along episodes 1 to 5 are streaming now. Ensure you don't miss a thing with our Agatha All Along release schedule

For more on the wider MCU, check out our guide to all of the upcoming Marvel movies and shows or get up to speed with our breakdown of the Marvel timeline.

Amy West

I am an Entertainment Writer here at GamesRadar+, covering all things TV and film across our Total Film and SFX sections. Elsewhere, my words have been published by the likes of Digital Spy, SciFiNow, PinkNews, FANDOM, Radio Times, and Total Film magazine.

Read more
Debra Jo Rupp as Sharon in Agatha All Along
A quickly killed off Agatha All Along star thought she'd be a witch: "I get there and no one is really looking me in the eye"
Wanda Maximoff, the Scarlet Witch
The Russo brothers hid an Avengers Easter egg in Netflix movie The Electric State ahead of their Marvel comeback – and I'm convinced it's teasing Scarlet Witch's return
Daredevil: Born Again
After a comics Easter egg was spotted, Daredevil: Born Again fans now think that [SPOILER] is secretly alive
Kathryn Hahn as Agatha in Marvel TV series Agatha All Along
Agatha All Along season 2 won't be happening according to one of its stars, who reveals showrunner also turned down WandaVision season 2
Karen Page (Deborah Ann Woll) and Daredevil/Matt Murdock (Charlie Cox) in Daredevil Born Again
Daredevil fans are theorizing about why Matt Murdock hung up the mask, and some of the suggestions are seriously dark
Thunderbolts* trailer
The latest Thunderbolts trailer all but confirms a major Marvel fan theory that one character is a goner
Latest in Marvel TV Shows
Tony Dalton as Jack Duquesne
Daredevil: Born Again fans are loving the MCU cameos in this week's episodes – especially the Hawkeye reunion
Daredevil: Born Again episode 6
Daredevil: Born Again's long-awaited moment has been called "pure cinema" featuring one of the "best lines in comic book movie history"
Daredevil looking mean and moody.
Daredevil: Born Again episode 5 just nodded to Thanos and the Avengers movies in the most obscure way
Daredevil: Born Again
Daredevil: Born Again has pulled another scene straight from the comics – and it's one of the darkest moments yet
Muse
Daredevil: Born Again midseason trailer teases Matt Murdock’s violent fight with Muse, including a gory scene straight from the comics
Iman Vellani in The Marvels
Daredevil: Born Again episode 5 gives an important Ms. Marvel update – and it might have confirmed a major team-up in the next Avengers movie
Latest in News
Lies of P art showing P walking in a snowy forest
Lies of P director loves FromSoftware and respects the Soulslike tag, but says "I'm really serious, I'm not lying, I'm very truthful, our focus is to create our own style of game"
Tony Dalton as Jack Duquesne
Daredevil: Born Again fans are loving the MCU cameos in this week's episodes – especially the Hawkeye reunion
Chris Hemsworth's name on the back of a director's chair
Marvel's Avengers: Doomsday cast reveal live blog
Screenshots from the Alien Evolved Edition TRPG teaser trailer
Alien Evolved Edition TRPG just burst through the million dollar crowdfunding mark with the vigor of a face-hugger on steroids
Halloween director John Carpenter
15 years on from his last horror movie, Halloween's John Carpenter says he'd "love to direct again" – but he has one condition
Lies of P Overture art of P
Lies of P director says Overture DLC is at least 15 to 20 hours long for "experienced" players, packing tons of bosses and ideas the devs couldn't fit at launch