The Boys finale changed a scene because of Karl Urban's "heartbreakingly great" acting – and the showrunner thinks he deserves awards

Karl Urban and Jeffrey Dean Morgan in The Boys season 4
(Image credit: Prime Video)

The Boys creator Eric Kripke has explained a last-minute change he made to the season 4 finale, and how it was all down to Karl Urban's "top shelf" acting as Billy Butcher in the emotional scene.

"So this Butcher scene KILLED me. Originally, we planned to cut back & forth between him & Hughie," he told his followers on X, formerly known as Twitter. "But was so heartbreakingly great, we just held on him. He's delivering top shelf, Emmy winning work here consistently."

In the sequence, and be warned, we're going to get a little spoiler-heavy from here on out, Hughie and Butcher share an achingly melancholy (but predictably lewd) phone call, as the latter recovers in the hospital after falling unconscious at the bar in the previous episode.

"We need your help," Hughie says over the line, but Butcher starts trailing off in only a way Butcher can. "When I was a lad," he begins, "I heard about this place in Nevada. A steakhouse, where the birds get their baps out when they bring you a ribeye. Lenny nearly pissed himself when I told him," he continues, mentioning his late younger brother. "Thought it was the funniest thing he ever heard. We was gonna go there someday. Well... Funny what you think about when your time's up, innit?"

"Butcher, where are you? I can come to you. We can figure this out," Hughie replies solemnly, to which Urban's character says: "Do us a favor, would you, Hughie? Go there. For me and Len, would ya? And tell the Boys I'm sorry, would ya? Tell the Boys I'm sorry for, uh... Just tell 'em I'm sorry. Goodbye, Hughie."

Kripke recently teased what to expect from The Boys' upcoming fifth and final season, suggesting it'll present "the show's version of the apocalypse" as the titular anti-Supe group make a last ditch attempt to stop Homelander from, well, taking over the world?

"The Boys are at their lowest point; most of them are captured, and we worry for their future," he told LadBible. "I always look at it [like we're at] the end of the second act of a movie, where everyone's really at their low point, and they've all faced their own personal demons. Now, they need to really come together in the fifth season and save the world."

The Boys seasons 1-4 are streaming now on Prime Video. The Boys season 5 is currently in development. For more on the show, check out some of our more spoiler-heavy explainers below:

Amy West

I am an Entertainment Writer here at GamesRadar+, covering all things TV and film across our Total Film and SFX sections. Elsewhere, my words have been published by the likes of Digital Spy, SciFiNow, PinkNews, FANDOM, Radio Times, and Total Film magazine.

Read more
Hughie in The Boys season 1
The Boys season 5 gets a bloody update from Hughie star in gory behind the scenes snap: "Work's been going great guys"
The Boys season 5: Karl Urban as William "Billy" Butcher punching an enemy during The Boys season 4.
The Boys season 5 release date speculation, cast, plot, and more news
Jack Quaid as Hughie in The Boys
Jack Quaid’s favorite The Boys moment is an iconic scene that was actually more dangerous than you think
Antony Starr as Homelander and Cameron Crovetti as Ryan during one of the best shows on Amazon Prime, The Boys.
The Boys showrunner Erik Kripke says scripts for season 5 are "half-written" despite filming being under way
The Boys season 3
The Boys fans have some big theories about where Eric Kripke will take Soldier Boy in season 5
Mark in the blue suit during the Invincible season 3 ending
Invincible season 3 ending explained: who dies, Eve's new powers, and Conquest's fate
Latest in Superhero Shows
Debra Jo Rupp as Sharon in Agatha All Along
A quickly killed off Agatha All Along star thought she'd be a witch: "I get there and no one is really looking me in the eye"
Peacemaker
Peacemaker season 2 star says the show feels like the DCU's "cool kid" as it's one of James Gunn's "first babies": "I'm excited to see how that expands and grows"
Mark Grayson in Invincible season 3
Voice acting is "complete" on Invincible season 4, which is a major boost to its 2026 release plans
Jack Quaid and Jensen Ackles in The Boys
Soldier Boy-centred The Boys prequel adds two stars in mystery roles for the upcoming superhero show
Mark Grayson in Invincible season 3
Invincible creator reveals fan-favorite villain is already cast ahead of season 4: "He's amazing"
Mark Grayson in Invincible season 3
Invincible season 3 video shows just how well the Conquest fight was adapted from the comics
Latest in News
Ezra Bridger in Ahsoka
A Star Wars actor just quietly confirmed that filming has begun on Ahsoka season 2
Mario
A surprise bonus Nintendo Direct is coming a week early: "There will be no updates about Nintendo Switch 2 during this presentation"
God of War
20 years later, God of War's original monster art has been revealed: behold this army of stick figures slapped on a whiteboard, no clue Kratos is coming for them
Assassin's Creed Shadows Naoe facing off against samurai warrior on red bridge
An Assassin's Creed Shadows fan is showing off some of the RPG's most impressive little details, and it's done more to get me interested than Ubisoft ever did
A woman chasing a shining butterfly with a leaping cat on her shoulder in InZOI
InZoi has a long way to go before it can actually rival The Sims as its director says EA's "spent decades perfecting" the formula
The T6 Power Armor
I'm about to spend over $400 on this iconic T60 Power Armor figurine because "Communism is the very definition of failure"