Flashpoint Beyond #4 reveals the surprising identity of the Clockwork Killer

Flashpoint Beyond #4 art
Flashpoint Beyond #4 art (Image credit: DC)

Flashpoint Beyond has not just been a return to the Flashpoint Universe, but an expansion of it. Regular continuity characters like Jason Woodrue have joined the formerly-dead world, and plotlines that had been extinguished, such as the war between Atlantis and Themyscira, have been reignited. But perhaps the most intriguing, or at least the most mysterious addition to the Flashpoint Universe is the Clockwork Killer, an enigmatic villain whose true identity has been concealed.

Until now.

Flashpoint Beyond #4 cover (Image credit: DC)

Flashpoint Beyond #4 is drawn by Xermánico and Mikel Janin, written by Geoff Johns, Tim Sheridan, and Jeremy Adams, colored by Romulo Fajardo Jr. and Jordie Bellaire, and lettered by Rob Leigh. The issue came out on August 2, and it sees Thomas Wayne's Batman investigating the latest victim of the Clockwork Killer (we'll tell you who in just a sec). By the end, he discovers who the killer is, and it's someone we've met before.

If it's not already obvious...

Spoilers ahead for August 2's Flashpoint Beyond #4

Up until now, we've known two things about the Clockwork Killer: First, that they leave clock parts inside their victims. Second, that they have something to do with the return of the Flashpoint Universe. That latter fact is what has kept Thomas obsessed with the case and made it more important to him than any other issue on his world (like, say, the incoming Kryptonian invasion). The former might be his only clue, but it's something he's yet to understand at all…

Issue #4 begins with Thomas removing clock parts from the killer's latest victim, Eobard Thawne. Yes, you read that right - Reverse Flash has been temporarily resurrected, only to be put down by our mysterious serial killer. As Thomas ponders over Thawne's reappearance in this reality, it occurs to him that maybe the cogs and gears Clockwork is leaving aren't a signature at all, but part of a puzzle. And perhaps the key to unmasking the killer is solving it.

Meanwhile, another issue that Thomas has chosen to ignore has reached its breaking point. Dexter Dent, son of the recently murdered Harvey and institutionalized Gilda, has decided that he's not happy with staying in Wayne Manor (see issue #1). Using the gear and training he picked up from Thomas when he semi-adopted him, Dexter becomes the Flashpoint version of Robin. His first mission: to break his mother out of Arkham Asylum.

the Flashpoint Beyond Robin

the Flashpoint Beyond Robin (Image credit: DC)

Down in the Batcave, Thomas's puzzle is beginning to come together. He was right; the parts are all from the same clock. There's only one problem - the final piece of the clock is missing. Or is it? In a moment of terrifying realization, Thomas discovers that he knows exactly where the final piece of the clock is. It's upstairs in Wayne Manor.

Over at Arkham Asylum, the Pre-Teen of Terror, Dexter, has snuck by security and capacitated the guards (is it any wonder criminals are breaking out of there all the time?). Using one of their keycards, Dexter gains access to Gilda's room. He wraps his arms around his mother, but the moment is anything from sweet. Half of Gilda's face is gone, leading us to believe she's the "Two-Face" of Flashpoint. But even worse, Gilda and Dexter are not alone. There's a voice coming from behind the wall. Just as, across town, Thomas understands what the clock parts mean, the wall in Arkham opens to reveal…

The Joker, AKA Martha Wayne.

a page from Flashpoint Beyond #4 (Image credit: DC)

Readers familiar with the Flashpoint universe recall that Martha's Joker was introduced in the alternate-world story Batman: Knight of Vengeance. In this grim tale, it's revealed that Martha Wayne went mad after her son Bruce died. Carving a smile onto her face (a la Heath Ledger in The Dark Knight), Martha became a child murderer called the Joker and plagued her ex-husband for years.

At the end of that story, Thomas tells Martha that in the "real world," it's the two of them that die, and Bruce survives. At first, it looks like Martha's madness has abated, but then Thomas goes on to explain what happened to the "real" Bruce, that he became the Batman. This is too much for Martha, and she commits suicide.

So, what is Martha doing alive and back in the world of Flashpoint? Why has she taken the identity of the Clockwork Killer? And what does she have to do with Flashpoint's resurrection? We don't have all the pieces of the puzzle just yet, but just like the gears inside the Clockwork Killer's victims, we suspect time will tell.

Thomas Wayne's Batman versus Martha Wayne's Joker is a fascinating twist on one of comics' greatest rivalries. But did Knight of Vengeance make it into Newsarama's best Batman and Joker stories? You'll have to read it to find out.

Grant DeArmitt
Freelance writer

Grant DeArmitt is a NYC-based writer and editor who regularly contributes bylines to Newsarama. Grant is a horror aficionado, writing about the genre for Nightmare on Film Street, and has written features, reviews, and interviews for the likes of PanelxPanel and Monkeys Fighting Robots. Grant says he probably isn't a werewolf… but you can never be too careful. 

Read more
Young Bruce and Selina run.
Absolute Batman #3 teases a new origin for the Riddler and delves into Bruce and Selina's childhoods
Commander Star looks on as chaos erupts in Gotham City.
Who is Commander Star? Batman #156 reveals the secret identity of Gotham’s sinister new hero
Black Mask sees the Bat-Signal
Absolute Batman is finally allowing one underrated villain to reach his full potential
Absolute Batman.
Absolute Batman #5 pays homage to an iconic scene from The Dark Knight
Absolute Batman in action.
Absolute Batman innovates by presenting us with a Caped Crusader who is still a work in progress
We're Taking Everyone Down With Us #1
We're Taking Everyone Down With Us forces a young girl to reckon with her father's villainous legacy in a world of "superspies, power hungry madmen, and delusional world leaders"
Latest in Dc Comics
Absolute Batman in the snow.
Absolute Batman writer Scott Snyder teases the arrival of Robin, crossovers with Superman and Wonder Woman, and building up to the Joker
Cover art from Resurrection Man: Quantum Karma #1.
13 years after his New 52 series ended, cult DC hero Resurrection Man is back in Quantum Karma
Jo Mullein on the cover for Absolute Green Lantern #1.
Absolute Green Lantern puts Far Sector's Jo Mullein front and center as a cosmic mystery comes to Earth
Batman (2025) #1
DC’s new Batman relaunch finally has me excited to follow the Caped Crusader again
Peacemaker and Eagly.
DC's new Peacemaker comic takes place in the universe of the show – and James Gunn was its story consultant
Absolute Wonder Woman in a vortex.
Absolute Wonder Woman's new lasso changes everything
Latest in News
Baldur's Gate 3 screenshot showing Astarion, a pale male elf with short curly white hair and red eyes, looking over his shoulder with a smirk on his face
Baldur's Gate 3 Astarion actor comes face to face with what might just be the best merch to come of the RPG yet – a 5-foot Funko Pop figure of his character
Drop
New horror movie starring White Lotus and Yellowstone actors gets a great Rotten Tomatoes score as early reactions call it the "perfect date night movie"
Lois and Peter in Family Guy season 23
After 11 years, Family Guy suddenly brings back a deep-cut character for season 23
Key art for Katamari Damacy Rolling LIVE showing the Prince rolling a Katamari as the King of All Cosmos sits at a livestreaming setup.
The first all-new Katamari Damacy game in almost 8 years is trapped in Apple Arcade jail, and I can only hope it follows in Hello Kitty Island Adventure's footsteps to eventually escape
Atomfall
Atomfall boss "very familiar" with Baldur's Gate 3 director's frustrations with publishers, as he recalls horror advice that games are "faster to make" if you "make fewer bugs"
The Rise of Skywalker
Despite those retirement reports, Lucasfilm boss Kathleen Kennedy is "very involved" in the Rey Star Wars movie, according to Daisy Ridley