Fool Me Once writer addresses Netflix show's plothole that left fans confused

Michelle Keegan and Emmett J. Scanlan in Fool Me Once
(Image credit: Netflix)

Harlan Coben, the author behind the novel that hit new Netflix thriller Fool Me Once is based on, has addressed a major detail that was bothering fans of the show: what was up with Shane (Emmet J. Scanlan)? Warning: Fool Me Once spoilers ahead!

The best friend of protagonist Maya (Michelle Keegan), a veteran and widow whose world is turned upside down when she sees her murdered husband (Richard Armitage) enter her home as an intruder on her nanny cam, Shane seemed suspicious of her throughout the show, placing trackers on her car and keeping watch outside of her house. Although it transpired that he was innocent, fans were still suspicious of him and felt that his actions weren't ever thoroughly explained. 

"I’m not gon lie... I thought Shane was a snake," tweeted one viewer. "Shane gives me weird vibes!! Something is off with him," agreed another. "Are we not going to talk about Shane's odd behavior when setting Maya's car alarm off? And standing outside her house at night?" wrote another fan. 

In the end, one viewer took to Twitter to get a definitive answer from Coben himself, asking: "Can you tell what the deal was with Shane?" 

"Spoiler: You’re military police," Coben replied. "Your best friend suffers PTSD. She is taking medication, lying to you, lost two close family members to murders, has you test a bullet — and says she’s seeing her dead husband. You might want to (track) keep an eye on her and her little girl…"

All eight episodes of Fool Me Once are now streaming on Netflix. If you have seen it all, we did a spoiler deep dive into the ending. For more, check out our picks of the other best Netflix shows to add to your watch list.

Entertainment Writer

I’m an Entertainment Writer here at GamesRadar+, covering everything film and TV-related across the Total Film and SFX sections. I help bring you all the latest news and also the occasional feature too. I’ve previously written for publications like HuffPost and i-D after getting my NCTJ Diploma in Multimedia Journalism. 

Read more
Gabriel Basso as Peter Sutherland in The Night Agent season 2
The Night Agent season 2 ending explained: Who dies in the Netflix show? Will there be a season 3?
Just One Look
A new "edge-of-your-seat" Harlan Coben thriller series has been quietly added to Netflix
Dichen Lachman as Ms. Casey in Severance
Severance's Adam Scott brutally shoots down one of the most plausible Gemma fan theories: "That's what Lumon would be doing in a super boring version of Severance"
fool me once
Fool Me Once author Harlan Coben’s new Netflix drama with "unbelievable twists and turns" begins filming this month: "It’s fantastic, vintage [Harlan]"
Adam Scott as Mark and Britt Lower as Helly in Severance season 2
Severance creator explains why reading fan theories about the Apple TV show can be so "overwhelming": "Sometimes I have to stop"
Adam Scott as Mark and Britt Lower as Helly in Severance season 2
Severance fans are convinced that's not really Helly R in the first episode of season 2
Latest in Thriller Shows
Penn Badgley and Charlotte Richie in You season 5
You season 5 trailer introduces Joe's new love interest and teases familiar faces in the final installment of the Netflix thriller
Noah Centineo in The Recruit
The Recruit fans are blaming The Night Agent for the show's cancelation: "It's Netflix's fault for releasing at the same time"
Noah Centineo in The Recruit season 2
Star of Netflix thriller show reveals sudden cancellation after two seasons: “Such a bummer”
Just One Look
A new "edge-of-your-seat" Harlan Coben thriller series has been quietly added to Netflix
Yellowjackets season 3
Yellowjackets season 3 episode 4's shock character death is a loss for the show, but proves the series is learning from season 2's mistakes
Yellowjackets
Who killed *spoiler* in Yellowjackets season 3? All our theories, explained
Latest in News
Jordan A. Mun looks at herself in a mirror in just a vest in Intergalactic: The Heretic Prophet screenshot
5 years after starting development, Neil Druckmann says Naughty Dog's new game Intergalactic: The Heretic Prophet is "still evolving and changing as we're making it"
Silent Hill f
After 2 years of silence, the next mainline Silent Hill game is getting a dedicated stream this week with "the latest news"
Original Xbox console
Former Microsoft exec says the first Xbox was killed early in favor of 360 because it was "losing money left right and center," but luckily "we could afford to hemorrhage cash"
A Monster Hunter Wilds character holding binoculars.
Despite Monster Hunter Wilds suffering monstrous performance problems on PC, it still outsold the PS5 and Xbox Series X versions in the US
Jordan A. Mun looks at herself in a mirror in just a vest in Intergalactic: The Heretic Prophet screenshot
The Last of Us creator Neil Druckmann says Intergalactic: The Heretic Prophet will also be about "being lonely," as if his zombie apocalypse wasn’t isolating enough: "I really want you to be lost"
A screenshot of Jordan drinking a soda during the reveal trailer for Intergalactic: The Hertic Prophet.
Intergalactic: The Heretic Prophet is "a game about faith and religion," which Neil Druckmann jokes will surely get less hate than The Last of Us 2