Paradox exec admits canceled life sim Life By You wasn't "actually clearly better than Sims 4 in any of its main areas"

Life By You
(Image credit: Paradox)

Paradox Interactive chief creative officer Henrik Fåhraeus says the canceled life sim Life By You wasn't actually better than The Sims 4 in any major way.

Life By You was positioned as a direct competitor to The Sims 4 before it was canceled in June 2024. However, in a new interview with Game File (paywalled), Fåhraeus admits it failed to deliver.

"An early access game needs, I think, needs to be really, really polished and fun, what's there, at least," Fåhraeus says. "You can have a lot of missing stuff in the late game and be very thin on content. But it needs to be a really good experience. And I don't think this could have been that for the foreseeable future.

"I also don't think that it was actually clearly better than Sims 4 in any of its main areas."

As if it needs to be said, that's an incredibly damning statement from the top of a game's publisher positioned to compete with The Sims 4. And believe it or not, it's debatable whether this is the most damning thing we've heard from Paradox about Life By You. Back when the game was canceled, Fåhraeus had this to say: "We thought maybe another extension will get us where we're going and then finally realized everything will be worse if we keep going, so we have to stop."

Fåhraeus also said at the time that, "A lot of the flaws were super clear and we saw the flaws individually."

The exact reason for the cancelation has never been made explicitly clear, but at least judging from these comments, it sounds like the game just wasn't very good, which is a shame because The Sims could've really used some competition in the space.

At least we have these great games like Sims to play.

CATEGORIES
Jordan Gerblick

After scoring a degree in English from ASU, I worked as a copy editor while freelancing for places like SFX Magazine, Screen Rant, Game Revolution, and MMORPG on the side. Now, as GamesRadar's west coast Staff Writer, I'm responsible for managing the site's western regional executive branch, AKA my apartment, and writing about whatever horror game I'm too afraid to finish.

Read more
Big in 2025: inZOI
inZOI's "community simulation" approach to the life sim genre could make it The Sims 4's biggest rival yet
Screenshot from inZOI showing two characters talking.
InZOI director hopes the Sims rival will be "successful and beloved," continues moonlighting as a philosopher: "Life is a tragedy when seen up close, but a comedy when viewed from a distance"
inZOI Character Studio trailer screenshot showing a young woman with ginger-y hair and a light baseball cap smiling to the side
InZOI director says it isn't a competitor to The Sims, but "another option" and a "different experience" with "in-depth customization" and AI-powered tools
A female sim in a red dress in front of a fire in an official Sims 1 render.
The Sims design mastermind Will Wright says the first Sims ever made were "too good" at staying alive and needed to be stupider for the game to be fun
Screenshot of My Little Life showing a large house sitting on the bottom of a desktop
If The Sims re-release isn't to your liking, this lovely life sim that lives on the bottom of your screen might fill the void
Proxi
The Sims creator's first game in over 10 years is an AI life sim that uses your real memories: "The more I can make a game about you, the more you'll like it"
Latest in Simulation
Let's Build a Dungeon
"They will cancel their subscription and your investors will have your head": This management sim about making the perfect MMO is so detailed it lets you play your own game
Cities: Skylines 2
Cities: Skylines 2 on console is still delayed at least until summer as devs work on "improving performance and stability"
Stardew Valley
With another "thank you," Stardew Valley creator Eric Barone brings an update arc to a close with "the Switch patch to fix the last Switch patch"
inZOI Character Studio trailer showing a young woman with ginger-y long hair and a white baseball cap smiling, her hand against her chin
The Sims 4's hyper-realistic competitor inZOI will only "sort of" have sex – but I'm sure a Wicked Whims-style mod will take care of the rest
a bulldozer on a dirt road
We all yearn for construction jobs as simulator RoadCraft takes a podium spot in Steam Next Fest's most-played demos just behind PvP mech game Mecha Break
Screenshot from inZOI showing two characters talking.
InZOI director hopes the Sims rival will be "successful and beloved," continues moonlighting as a philosopher: "Life is a tragedy when seen up close, but a comedy when viewed from a distance"
Latest in News
Alien Earth teaser
New Alien: Earth teaser introduces us to new cast members and the cutest little cat – and if a Xenomorph eats it, I will be furious
Three RTX 5070 gaming PCs on a purple background
I'm surprised to see some RTX 5070 gaming PCs under $2,000, and these are the ones I'd buy
Let's Build a Dungeon
"They will cancel their subscription and your investors will have your head": This management sim about making the perfect MMO is so detailed it lets you play your own game
Mark Ruffalo and Toni Collette in Mickey 17
Although the Mickey 17 cast were at first baffled by the unique way Parasite director Bong Joon Ho works, now they want it no other way
Hollow Knight
Day 1,251: Hollow Knight's strongest soldier has been fighting the boss version of Silksong star Hornet every day for over 3 years, and watching them master the Metroidvania in real time is truly amazing
Chris Pine and Michelle Rodriguez in Dungeons & Dragons: Honor Among Thieves
The Monopoly movie from Margot Robbie's production company will be written by the Dungeons and Dragons movie directors