Glass Onion theory explains why a major Knives Out twist isn't a plot hole

Glass Onion
(Image credit: Netflix)

Glass Onion has been impressing viewers on Netflix, climbing up the streaming charts and winning over critics. However, there was one plot point that had a lot of people confused in Rian Johnson’s Knives Out sequel.

Of course, in order to get into this, we’ll be discussing major plot points from the movie. So if you’re still hoping to avoid Glass Onion spoilers, bookmark this page for later.

If you’re still here, you’ll know that the plot hinges around Miles Bron (Edward Norton) inviting a group of his friends to a private Greek island. Among those he invites is his former business partner Andi Brand (Janelle Monáe), who we later find out he killed to stop the real origins of his company from coming to light.

Given this is the big twist, some viewers have been wondering why Miles even invited Andi to the island in the first place after killing her. However, one viewer might have worked out what really happened.

Posting on Reddit (H/T Digital Spy), a user pointed out that Miles likely sent the invitations long before he murdered Andi. Based on the movie’s timeline, it seems that the Andi and Miles court case took place only a few months before the film, while Andi emailed everyone about the napkin about a week before the trip. 

"Miles says his puzzle guy barely got the boxes done in time," the Redditor argues. "That's because he was making five boxes and not four. Blanc is told that Miles does a big gathering like this every year. I believe that he set all this up a year ago (further supported by him hiring Gillian Flynn to write the mystery)."

They continued: "I think he forgot to cancel the fifth box after the trial when it was already being constructed. Miles is the kind of guy who just throws money at things and forgets about it until some shiny new toy shows up."

It’s certainly an interesting idea and given Miles is referred to as an idiot throughout the movie, it would be in character. As well as this, other Redditors pointed out that Miles would likely have aroused some suspicion if he canceled Andi’s box after killing her too, adding fuel to why she received an invite. 

For more on the Netflix movie, check out our breakdown of the Glass Onion ending, all the Glass Onion cameos you might have missed, and some of the best Glass Onion Easter eggs that we spotted.

Fay Watson
Deputy Entertainment Editor

I’m the Deputy Entertainment Editor here at GamesRadar+, covering TV and film for the Total Film and SFX sections online. I previously worked as a Senior Showbiz Reporter and SEO TV reporter at Express Online for three years. I've also written for The Resident magazines and Amateur Photographer, before specializing in entertainment.

Read more
Dichen Lachman as Ms. Casey in Severance
Severance's Adam Scott brutally shoots down one of the most plausible Gemma fan theories: "That's what Lumon would be doing in a super boring version of Severance"
Yellowjackets
Who killed *spoiler* in Yellowjackets season 3? All our theories, explained
seven
Seven director David Fincher shares what was actually in the box, though he says "you don't need to see what's in the box if you have Morgan Freeman"
Theo James in The Monkey
The Monkey's Tatiana Maslany reacts to the horror movie's most shocking death: "It's so wrong, and I think that's why it's so right"
The toy monkey in Osgood Perkins' new horror comedy The Monkey
The Monkey ending explained: Who dies and is the curse broken?
Adam Scott as Mark and Britt Lower as Helly in Severance season 2
Severance creator explains why reading fan theories about the Apple TV show can be so "overwhelming": "Sometimes I have to stop"
Latest in Drama Movies
Bloodsport
The 32 greatest '80s action movies
Cosmo Jarvis
Christopher Nolan's The Odyssey adds Shogun star to its massively star-studded cast, and I'm getting Oppenheimer vibes all over again
Adrien Brody in The Brutalist
This year's Best Actor Oscars speech broke a record that was over 80 years old
Adrien Brody as László Tóth in The Brutalist
Oscars 2025 live coverage: All the winners, red carpet, and the 97th Academy Awards' biggest moments – as it happens
The Last Showgirl
Beneath the glitz and glam of The Last Showgirl is a heartbreaking story about what mothers give up
Kieran Culkin and Jesse Eisenberg in A Real Pain
Kieran Culkin wins Best Supporting Actor at the Oscars 2025 and makes a hilarious and heartfelt dedication to his wife: "Ye of little faith"
Latest in News
Ultima Online
As Ultima Online approaches its 28th birthday, former creative lead reveals what it takes for an MMO to last for decades, and why they sometimes fail: "Content does not last forever"
Link and Epona
A Zelda movie is finally happening, but Nintendo's Shigeru Miyamoto used to adamantly oppose the idea even "if Steven Spielberg himself" wanted to do it
Robert Downey Jr announces his Doctor Doom casting at San Diego Comic-Con 2024
"He is so dialed in": Robert Downey Jr. is coming up with backstory and costume ideas for Doctor Doom ahead of Avengers: Doomsday
Stardew Valley
With another "thank you," Stardew Valley creator Eric Barone brings an update arc to a close with "the Switch patch to fix the last Switch patch"
Demon Slayer Infinity Castle
Over 80 countries and 42 days: the first Demon Slayer Infinity Castle movie's remarkable staggered release plans have been revealed – including a US date
Monster Hunter Wilds
Monster Hunter Wilds' story is as divisive as expected: some players hate the "relentless on rails handholding," others love the build-up to "the best scene in Monster Hunter history"