The compact Xbox Game Bar is fine, but I hope it’s not a Windows handheld bandage

Xbox Game Bar compact mode on Ayaneo Flip DS with recent games list tab open
(Image credit: Future / Phil Hayton)

I’ve been waiting for Microsoft to weigh in with a Windows gaming handheld solution for a while, and it arguably just took its first steps with the new compact Game Bar. Available to members of the company’s Xbox Insider program, the latest update aims to make the PC overlay more usable on portable devices. Naturally, I’ve been testing the app extension since the announcement to get a feel for what it offers, and while it’s serviceable, it’s anything but a proper solution.

I’m trying to avoid sounding grumpy, as the compact Xbox Game Bar is going to help some of the best gaming handhelds out there. Specifically, it should give devices like the Asus ROG Ally a way to tweak settings and launch games without using either the Windows desktop or a third-party app like Armoury Crate. My initial concern with this approach is that it’s more or less another middleman, serving to implement on an operating system that has no interest in on-the-go usability. 

I’m using the Ayaneo Flip DS to test the compact Xbox Game Bar recently announced via Xbox Wire. In theory, the experience should be the same as when using the ROG Ally or Lenovo Legion Go since they all use Windows 11, but your mileage could vary if your chosen device has specific firmware active in the background. I also had a bit of trouble getting the new overlay option to appear in the first place, as I had to re-install the Xbox app multiple times from the Microsoft Store to get up and running. I’m trying not to let that faff set the the tone here, but it does tie into the overall clunky nature of the Windows gaming experience. 

A night at the Game Bar 

For those of you unacquainted, the Xbox Game Bar adds quick access to console-like functionality like screenshots, social elements, and audio mixing dials. There are also a small range of widgets you can grab that’ll let you use apps like Spotify while in-game rather than having to head back to the desktop. 

Sounds ideal for handhelds, right? Well, the new compact mode helps resize everything for smaller portable screens making the UI a bit more controller and touch-friendly. All the above functionality remains the same, but some of the changes lean more towards quickly launching games. This was one of the first elements I noticed, as the “recent game” list now takes center stage at the front of the Game Bar. You won’t be able to access your full PC library from here since it’ll only retain a shortlist, meaning you’ll still have to rely on Steam and other storefronts, but the larger menu is appreciated.

Of course, you can also launch the main storefront apps and things like Armory Crate using the compact game bar, saving you once again from faffing around with desktop icons. I’m not entirely convinced this is a more effective approach, as you’re still going to end up thrown into various other screens before eventually reaching your game of choice, and it’s still extremely tempting just to use Steam Big Picture mode from the get-go. 

Handheld overlay hangover 

(Image credit: Future / Phil Hayton)

Perhaps I’ve been spoiled by the console-like convenience provided by the Steam Deck OLED and SteamOS, but the compact Xbox Game Bar feels like anything but a substitute. Even when judging just as an overlay rather than a full-blown management app, the tool is missing various handy handheld features that would save players ever looking at the Windows desktop or taskbar.

The first relates to power management settings, as you’re still going to either use your handheld’s specific app (in my case AyaSpace) or Windows settings to adjust things like wattage, battery life, or even resolution. Had the Game Bar included some of these options within its toolbox, it would have brought some of those more hard-to-interact-with elements out from within OS menus and into a controller-friendly space. 

Another element that feels slightly half-baked is the Game Bar’s performance tab, as I couldn’t see a way to pin it on screen in compact mode. Being able to do that would mean you could run through specific sections of a game and have an FPS counter in view, but the current format means you’ll have to stop playing to look at any metrics. For context, the Steam Deck and Windows handhelds like the ROG Ally can display stats in a small box in the corner of your display using its own sidebar overlay.

(Image credit: Future / Phil Hayton)

While testing the compact Game Bar, I kept asking myself whether I’d use it instead of existing management apps or even just Steam Big Picture Mode. The short answer is no, as the functionality it provides is pretty basic. Admittedly, Microsoft didn’t pitch this update as a way to turn your handheld into a portable Xbox or even eliminate the need for Windows interaction.

However, this is the first meaningful update that targets the Windows handheld experience, so it's understandable that players may have been expecting something a bit more revolutionary. All the company has done in this instance is scaled the UI for the existing game bar. That could be considered a step in the right direction, but I’m hoping it's not just a bandaid to appease anyone who’s now invested in the platform for portable gaming. 


Already got Valve’s handheld? Swing by the best Steam Deck accessories and best Steam Deck dock for a range of add-ons. Alternatively, check out the best gaming laptop if you want something with more oomph.

TOPICS
CATEGORIES
Phil Hayton
Hardware Editor

I’ve been messing around with PCs, video game consoles, and tech since before I could speak. Don’t get me wrong, I kickstarted my relationship with technology by jamming a Hot Wheels double-decker bus into my parent’s VCR, but we all have to start somewhere. I even somehow managed to become a walking, talking buyer’s guide at my teenage supermarket job, which helped me accept my career fate. So, rather than try to realise my musician dreams, or see out my University degree, I started running my own retro pop culture site and writing about video games and tech for the likes of TechRadar, The Daily Star, and the BBC before eventually ending up with a job covering graphics card shenanigans at PCGamesN. Now, I’m your friendly neighbourhood Hardware Editor at GamesRadar, and it’s my job to make sure you can kick butt in all your favourite games using the best gaming hardware, whether you’re a sucker for handhelds like the Steam Deck and Nintendo Switch or a hardcore gaming PC enthusiast.

Read more
Lenovo Legion Go S with Xbox logo on screen next to white Series X controller on woodgrain surface
The rumored Xbox handheld isn't what you think, and I'm hoping it'll solve my Windows 11 problems
Xbox Gamescom 2023 logo featuring a stylized city skyline in green
Microsoft says it's working on "bringing the best of Xbox and Windows together" to make handheld gaming better, and it should have more to share this year
Hands holding Alienware gaming handheld "Concept UFO" with city in backdrop
Sorry, an Alienware gaming handheld isn't on the way, but Dell says its looking "pretty heavily” at the space
Asus ROG Flow Z13 with Asus ROG Ally handheld
This gaming tablet's processor could be the holy grail for handhelds
Lenovo Legion Go S with FlyKnight gameplay on screen featuring player character holding bow and arrow with enemy ant in backdrop.
Lenovo Legion Go S Windows 11 review: “my heart aches for this mixed up handheld”
iPad Air running PlayStation remote play with a DualSense controller next to it
Should you buy a gaming tablet in 2025?
Latest in Handhelds
Lenovo Legion Go S with Steam Big Picture Mode on screen with pink and blue lights in backdrop.
Lenovo Legion Go S SteamOS pre-orders are now live, and I'm hoping it's a second wind for the handheld
OneXPlayer OneXSugar1 handhelds with one on left featuring screen detached and right hand device with dual-screens.
Qualcomm just revealed its latest Snapdragon chips, and the G3 Gen 3 will power what could be my dream 3DS handheld
Baseus 6-in-1 Steam Deck dock with OLED model sitting in cradle next to Asus controller and Samsung TV with game menu in backdrop.
I've tested over 20 different docking stations since the Steam Deck landed, but there's one I always go back to
Lenovo Legion Go S with FlyKnight gameplay on screen featuring player character holding bow and arrow with enemy ant in backdrop.
Lenovo Legion Go S Windows 11 review: “my heart aches for this mixed up handheld”
Lenovo Legion Go S with Xbox logo on screen next to white Series X controller on woodgrain surface
The rumored Xbox handheld isn't what you think, and I'm hoping it'll solve my Windows 11 problems
Mario & Luigi: Brothership trailer still
The end is nigh for the 3DS as Nintendo runs out of parts for 2 more models in Japan, with only 1 iteration still accepted for repairs
Latest in Features
Kill Team: Blood and Zeal box on a wooden surface
Kill Team: Blood and Zeal pre-orders just went live, and I wish other Warhammer games were this weird
Batman, Superman, and Wonder Woman.
DC June 2025 solicitations: 10 must-have comics to pre-order this month
Flow
Flow won big as this year's Oscars underdog against Pixar and Netflix, and it's proof of the power of storytelling over dialogue
Yasuke riding through a village looking for Knowledge in Assassin's Creed Shadows
Assassin's Creed Shadows' prologue is the most gripping in franchise history, but I'm fixated on the tiny details
Naoe blends in among lush trees in Assassin's Creed Shadows while observing Amagasaki Castle from a rooftop perch
After 18 years Assassin's Creed Shadows cracks the ultimate stealth loop with its deliciously dense castles
Naoe perched in front of a castle in Assassin's Creed Shadows
I've spent 20 hours in Assassin's Creed Shadows chasing drip and decor, and it's proving to be my biggest source of motivation in the RPG