Doctor Strange 2's What If cameo explained

What If...?
(Image credit: Marvel Studios)

Doctor Strange in the Multiverse of Madness is full of exciting cameos, some recognizable and some that might have left you scratching your head.

Fans of Marvel's animated series What If... will definitely recognize one cameo in particular, though they appear in live-action form. If you haven't seen Doctor Strange 2, turn back now because there are major spoilers ahead.

Read on to find out more about that familiar face in Doctor Strange 2.

Doctor Strange in the Multiverse of Madness

(Image credit: Marvel Studios)

If you've made it this far, then you know that Hayley Atwell appears in Doctor Strange in the Multiverse of Madness. 

She's not playing the Peggy Carter we know and love from the Captain America movies or Agent Carter TV series, though. This is an entirely different version of the character drawn from the multiverse – but one we've met before in What If. 

Who does Hayley Atwell play in Doctor Strange 2?

Atwell plays none other than Captain Carter in Doctor Strange 2. She was introduced in the very first episode of What If, which saw Peggy Carter undergo the Super Soldier transformation instead of Steve Rogers. She then became Captain Carter, who wields a Union Jack-emblazoned shield and fights in World War 2. 

But, Captain Carter ends up sucked through a portal while fighting a giant tentacle creature, and emerges 70 years in the future. She then becomes a member of the Guardians of the Multiverse after teaming up with Party Thor, Star-Lord T'Challa, Black Panther Killmonger, Doctor Strange Supreme, Gamora, and Black Widow to beat an all-powerful Ultron. 

In Doctor Strange 2, she's a member of the Illuminati, and fights Wanda Maximoff when she arrives for America Chavez.

Will Hayley Atwell play Captain Carter again?

What If...? finale

(Image credit: Disney/Marvel)

So far, Atwell has played Captain Carter every single time the character has appeared in the MCU, voicing her throughout What If and bringing her to live-action.

But in Doctor Strange 2, Peggy is brutally killed with her own shield by Scarlet Witch, who slaughters the rest of the Illuminati while she's at it. Whether that rules out a return for Captain Carter or not remains to be seen – after all, in the multiverse, anything is possible…

Is Doctor Strange 2's Captain Carter the same as What If's?

What If...?

(Image credit: Marvel Studios)

It's unclear just what version of Captain Carter this is. No mention is made of Carter's role as a Guardian of the Multiverse or her history from What If – plus, the Illuminati have Ultron guards, and after Peggy fought another version of the evil robot before, she'd probably be more wary of them. 

Then there's the fact that Captain Carter is confirmed to appear in every season of the animated show, which might be difficult considering her gruesome end at Scarlet Witch's hands. So, chances are this is a different version of Captain Carter, and she's safe to appear in future shows and movies down the line.


Want more on Doctor Strange in the Multiverse of Madness? Then check out our guides to: 

Molly Edwards
Senior Entertainment Writer

I'm a Senior Entertainment Writer here at GamesRadar+, covering all things film and TV for the site's Total Film and SFX sections. I previously worked on the Disney magazines team at Immediate Media, and also wrote on the CBeebies, MEGA!, and Star Wars Galaxy titles after graduating with a BA in English. 

Read more
Captain America: Brave New World trailer
Captain America: Brave New World cameos and Easter eggs: all the Marvel references you might have missed
Captain America: Brave New World
That Captain America: Brave New World cameo changed several times, but it was always going to be that character
Danny Ramirez and Anthony Mackie in Captain America: Brave New World
Captain America: Brave New World ending explained – Who dies in the Marvel movie? How does it set up the next Avengers?
The Illuminati and The Illuminati in Doctor Strange 2
Captain America: Brave New World post-credits scene teases the Illuminati reveals director after the group were axed from an early draft
WandaVision
Marvel star Elizabeth Olsen says she's enjoyed playing Scarlet Witch for over 10 years and would "love to keep doing more"
Sam Wilson in a dark room holding shield in Captain America: Brave New World
Captain America: Brave New World post-credits scenes: how many are there and what does it mean for the future of the MCU?
Latest in Supernatural Shows
Wednesday season 2
Jenna Ortega says Wednesday season 2 features a slasher themed episode and compares one moment to Kubrick's Full Metal Jacket
Lady Gaga as Harley Quinn in Joker 2
Wednesday star Jenna Ortega teases Lady Gaga's appearance in season 2 of the Netflix show: "It was just a really, really special environment"
Jenna Ortega in Wednesday
Creepy new look at Wednesday season 2 confirms Tyler's fate, as Jenna Ortega's hero embraces her darker side
Buffy: The Vampire Slayer
Sarah Michelle Gellar is more open than ever before to a Buffy revival – and the director of one of this year's best horror movies has already staked their claim on it
The Sandman season 2: Tom Sturridge as Dream in The Sandman season 1.
The Sandman season 2 release date speculation, cast, trailer, and more news
What If...? season 3
First look at What if…? season 3 is the first time we've seen Sam Wilson's Captain America since 2021 (yes, really)
Latest in News
Lady Dimitrescu and Austin Abrams
The new Resident Evil movie may have found a lead in a Euphoria star
Leatherface and Glen Powell
Glenn Powell could be taking a swing at a new Texas Chainsaw Massacre
Xenomorph in Alien: Earth
New Alien: Earth clip shows the last of another expendable crew
Adam Scott as Mark S and Britt Lower as Helly R in Severance season 2
There might have been another reason for Mark's decision in the Severance season 2 finale
Silent Hill f art showing a person covered in plants
Silent Hill f has been pre-emptively banned in Australia, with no reason given for the 'refused classification' rating
Assassin's Creed Shadows review gameplay showing Yasuke overlooking the sea and lush green scenery
Assassin's Creed Shadows has already "surpassed the launches of AC Origins and Odyssey" with 2 million players and counting