Hereditary fan thinks they figured out the film's greatest 'mystery,' which has been puzzling viewers for years

Hereditary
(Image credit: A24)

A horror fan has solved what they believe to be Hereditary's biggest mystery – and it's an accidental mix-up involving Aleister Crowley.

In Hereditary, Annie (Toni Collette) opens a spellbook to a chapter titled "Summoning King Paimon," which contains a drawing that depicts Paimon as wearing black robes, holding a staff, having a big triangle hat, and riding a camel. The Redditor points out that – camel aside – this is not the way that Paimon, described as the King of Hell in early grimoires, has been depicted throughout history.

But while you can assume that director Ari Aster was taking creative liberties and perhaps making Paimon a bit scarier looking for horror movie purposes, the Redditor believes Aster actually misinterpreted a drawing of Paimon and famed occultist Aleister Crowley – conflating one for the other. In the drawing, made by Crowley himself, Crowley (left) is seen summoning Paimon (right). Crowley is wearing a triangle hat and black robes. Paimon is mostly a scary floating head sitting on top of a camel. The theory here is that Aster mixed up the two, resulting in Paimon's depiction in the film. But, again, it's also possible that Aster combined the two for creative purposes. 

The fan also believes Aster mistook the camel for a horse, which is why there's hidden horse imagery throughout the film. 

One commenter doubts that it was a misinterpretation, arguing that Paimon has "been shown in a variety of forms throughout history" and that they are sure Aster "used the wealth of information that exists regarding the characteristics and features of Paimon". They also don't think Aster mistook a camel for a horse. 

And yeah, we're just as confused as you are.

Hereditary is streaming on Max. For more, check out our list of the most exciting upcoming movies in 2024 and beyond.

Lauren Milici
Senior Writer, Tv & Film

Lauren Milici is a Senior Entertainment Writer for GamesRadar+ currently based in the Midwest. She previously reported on breaking news for The Independent's Indy100 and created TV and film listicles for Ranker. Her work has been published in Fandom, Nerdist, Paste Magazine, Vulture, PopSugar, Fangoria, and more.

Read more
Lily-Rose Depp in Nosferatu
Nosferatu has a mistake so obscure you need to be bird expert to notice it – and fans joke that Robert Eggers will be "genuinely upset" when he discovers it
The toy monkey in Osgood Perkins' new horror comedy The Monkey
The Monkey ending explained: Who dies and is the curse broken?
Still from upcoming horror movie The Woman in the Yard
Blumhouse horror movie The Woman in the Yard's new trailer has genre fans trying to predict its twist – and some of their theories sound pretty plausible
Bill Skarsgard as Count Orlok in Nosferatu
There's actually a werewolf reference in a Nosferatu deleted scene, and it's sparked theories about a Robert Eggers connected universe
David Bowie in Labyrinth 1986
Nosferatu director Robert Eggers is making a sequel to one of my favorite childhood movies Labyrinth – and I have the perfect nightmarish storyline in mind
Nicolas Cage as Longlegs in Longlegs/Osgood Perkins and Nicolas Cage standing side-by-side at a Longlegs event
Longlegs director has shared his dream project outside of horror, and now we're hoping it happens
Latest in Horror Movies
Lady Dimitrescu and Austin Abrams
The new Resident Evil movie may have found a lead in a Euphoria star
Leatherface and Glen Powell
Glenn Powell could be taking a swing at a new Texas Chainsaw Massacre
Jai Courtney in Dangerous Animals
The first trailer for The Suicide Squad star's new serial killer movie makes Jaws look like Finding Nemo
The Bride
Maggie Gyllenhaal’s upcoming horror movie starring Christian Bale and Jessie Buckley gets delayed in big Warner Bros. shake-up
Alison Brie as Millie in new body horror Together
Alison Brie and Dave Franco's body horror with 100% Rotten Tomatoes score gets a chilling first trailer
The ghost of a young woman standing in front of a red door during the Netflix horror series, The Haunting of Hill House.
New Shudder horror starring Haunting of Hill House and Riverdale stars sounds like the perfect mix of The Craft and Mallrats
Latest in News
A screenshot from MindsEye showing a character leaning out of a car, shooting another car with a gun.
GTA veteran says the games industry needs to "get smarter" about what people actually want: "There are so many games, and I think we're starting to feel the effects"
Posing with a rifle in the Fallout 76 Ghoul update
Fallout 76's art director "had to fight really hard" so Bethesda would make the MMO's map bigger than Skyrim's
Minecraft movie image of Jack Black as steve
Don't expect Minecraft to go free-to-play anytime soon, as Mojang says "It doesn't really work with the way we built it"
Yasuke looking over the water to a shrine during sunset in Assassin's Creed Shadows
Assassin's Creed Shadows has an entire island stuffed with adorable kittens you need to check out, and it's based on an actual Japanese cat paradise
phase zero key art showing zombies in a hallway
Former Witcher 3 and Dying Light devs reveal their Resident Evil homage, complete with PS1-style fixed cameras
Shadow of Mordor's Nemesis System was only created because WB Games wanted something to combat Batman Arkham Asylum's second-hand sales, exec says