Here's why John Carpenter quit Red Dead Redemption

John Carpenter on Red Dead Redemption
(Image credit: Rockstar Games/Future)

Iconic horror director and lover of video games John Carpenter has more gaming opinions, including a hilarious reason for not playing the Red Dead Redemption series. Carpenter has spoken about his love for video games before, most notably praising Assassin's Creed Valhalla back in 2020, calling it an "incredible game" via his Twitter account. 

In a recent interview with The New Yorker, Carpenter (who famously avoids talking about his body of work) spoke candidly about his history with video games. He first started playing games in 1992 with Sonic the Hedgehog. "I play older stuff, but I play new stuff. I play all stuff," Carpenter says. When asked what he's playing right now, Carpenter is quick with a response.

"I’ve been playing this game for quite a while. It’s called Fallout 76. The Fallout games are fun, it’s like a post-apocalyptic world. This game had a rough launch, with problems and bugs, but I really like it. There’s this incredible game called Horizon Forbidden West. Astonishing game," he says. When the interviewer asks if Horizon Forbidden West is an immersive Western, the conversation shifts to Red Dead Redemption, which Carpenter never properly played for an absolutely hilarious (and understandable) reason. 

"I couldn’t get on the damn horse," he admits. "I gave up. It was too hard." To be fair, Rockstar's control scheme has always been a bit difficult for me to grasp. I, personally, felt immense levels of guilt and shame when playing Red Dead Redemption 2 because I kept accidentally punching my horse instead of mounting it. So, Mr. Carpenter, I see you, I hear you, I empathize with you. 

Don't call Jordan Peele the best horror director - he'll tell you it's John Carpenter.

Alyssa Mercante

Alyssa Mercante is an editor and features writer at GamesRadar based out of Brooklyn, NY. Prior to entering the industry, she got her Masters's degree in Modern and Contemporary Literature at Newcastle University with a dissertation focusing on contemporary indie games. She spends most of her time playing competitive shooters and in-depth RPGs and was recently on a PAX Panel about the best bars in video games. In her spare time Alyssa rescues cats, practices her Italian, and plays soccer.

Read more
Halloween director John Carpenter
15 years on from his last horror movie, Halloween's John Carpenter says he'd "love to direct again" – but he has one condition
Indiana Jones and the Great Circle
Indiana Jones and the Great Circle has a survival horror surprise that echoes Cyberpunk: Phantom Liberty's – and I loved every second
Red Dead Redemption 2
Games like Red Dead Redemption 2 to storm the old west with
Hideo Kojima side by side with I Saw The TV Glow
Hideo Kojima has just given his seal of approval to one of 2024's best but most underseen horror movies
Kingdom Come: Deliverance 2 screenshot of Henry riding on his grey horse Pebbles as his dog Mutt follows behind
I don't fast travel in Kingdom Come: Deliverance 2 to channel the immersive feel of Red Dead Redemption 2 and Cyberpunk 2077
Anya Taylor-Joy and Miles Teller as Drasa and Levi in The Gorge
Sinister director says his new horror film The Gorge is partly inspired by Silent Hill and Until Dawn: "I love those games"
Latest in Red Dead
Former PlayStation boss Shawn Layden says 100-hour games are a "mismatch" to today's reality: "I haven't even opened Red Dead Redemption 2, because I don't have 90 hours"
Red Dead Redemption 2 screenshot showing the silhouette of a man with a cowboy hat on horseback, a glowing sun seen behind him
Red Dead Redemption 2's very own Arthur Morgan says he wishes that he could work with "genius" Metal Gear mastermind Hideo Kojima
Red Dead Redemption 2
Red Dead Redemption 2 modder makes "all wagons and horses travel at super sonic speeds," chaos and jumpscares ensue: "It's now a horror game"
Red Dead Redemption
Red Dead Redemption 2 dev reveals detail "99% of people never saw" that's part of "what makes Rockstar's games so good"
Red Dead Redemption
Rockstar veteran says Red Dead Redemption's PS3 version was "very hard and time-consuming" to make, but it was "easy to write for the 360"
Red Dead Redemption
After 14 years, the original Red Dead Redemption finally hits PC this month, with Undead Nightmare in two
Latest in News
Daredevil: Born Again episode 6
Daredevil's Charlie Cox isn't in the Avengers: Doomsday cast list – but Marvel fans have an idea about how he might still show up
Simu Liu in Shang-Chi and the Legend of the Ten Rings
Simu Liu had the best reaction to Shang-Chi’s announcement for Avengers: Doomsday, but fans think it's "criminal" there hasn’t been a direct sequel
Mario faces the camera with a thumbs up pose in Super Smash Bros. Ulimate.
Nintendo Direct March 2025 live – all the Switch news, trailers, and reveals as they happen
Batman: Arkham Knight
Rocksteady's rumored single-player Batman game is in development for PC, PS5, Xbox, and "the next generation of consoles"
The Last of Us Part 1
The Last of Us director Neil Druckmann wanted to make sure the first game "was complete" because "I wasn't sure they would ever let me direct a game again"
Pillars of Eternity
10 years later, in a post-Baldur's Gate 3 and Avowed world, Obsidian is giving its own throwback CRPG Pillars of Eternity a turn-based combat mode