Hocus Pocus 2 called "charming", a "warm hug", and "uninspired" in mixed first reviews

Hocus Pocus 2
(Image credit: Disney)

Sarah Jessica Parker, Kathy Najimy, and Bette Midler are back as the Sanderson Sisters in the long-awaited sequel, Hocus Pocus 2 – which is now on Disney Plus. The first reviews are already in, and critics have mixed feelings about the magic-filled movie. 

Released in 1993, the original followed a young boy named Max (Omri Katz) who inadvertently resurrects witches Sarah, Winifred and Mary, endangering the Salem town he and his family move to just before Halloween. Its follow-up centers on a similar plot, as three young women unleash the child-hungry sorceresses. Whitney Peak, Belissa Escobedo, Lilia Buckingham, Sam Richardson, Tony Hale, and Ted Lasso's Hannah Waddingham also star, while Doug Jones appears as Winnie's zombified ex-boyfriend Billy Butcherson once again.

"Like many fan favorite follow-ups, Hocus Pocus 2 is stuck, trapped somewhere between different times, audiences and tones, trying to do so much yet, in this instance, achieving so very little," argues The Guardian's Benjamin Lee, while Independent's Amanda Whiting writes: "It's less menacing. It lacks the exquisite cuteness exuded by a middle-grade Thora Birch. There are zero talking cats. But that's unlikely to matter much to most audiences."

Den of Geek's David Crow claimed that while Hocus Pocus 2 is "leaps and bounds better than most second helpings of Disney nostalgia", the sequel "still can't climb out of its own grave." Elsewhere, Screen It! scribe Jim Judy was more scathing, describing the flick as "mediocre, flat, uninspired, and thus [as] forgettable as its predecessor."

Others found some merit in it, like ABC News' Peter Travers, who called it "bewitching" and Bloody Disgusting's Meagan Navarro says: "Nearly three decades later, the Sanderson sisters still cast a magical spell, offering a warm hug of nostalgic callbacks with a modern take on sisterhood."

"It manages to capture the same hokey magic of the original while creatively updating its humor," adds New York Times journalist Claire Shaffer, as London Evening Standard's Elizabeth Gregory awards it the full five out of five stars. "The banshees are more brilliantly bonkers than ever in this rollicking sequel," she gushes. 

At the time of writing, Hocus Pocus 2 has a 64% fresh rating on Rotten Tomatoes. It is available to stream on Disney Plus now, if you want to make up your own mind about it. Or, if sorcery-filled sequels aren't your bag, then check out the best movies on Disney Plus and the best shows on Disney Plus for some viewing inspiration.

Amy West

I am an Entertainment Writer here at GamesRadar+, covering all things TV and film across our Total Film and SFX sections. Elsewhere, my words have been published by the likes of Digital Spy, SciFiNow, PinkNews, FANDOM, Radio Times, and Total Film magazine.

Read more
Young Mufasa in Mufasa: The Lion King
Mufasa: The Lion King review – "It's no Hakuna Matata but this Disney origin story is a class above the 2019 movie"
Sarah Michelle Gellar in Buffy
The Buffy the Vampire Slayer reboot news was always going to be divisive, but it could be exactly what TV needs right now
Scoot McNairy as Ben and James McAvoy as Paddy in Speak No Evil
One of my favorite horror movies of 2024 is a remake I disregarded months ago based on its lackluster trailer - I won't make that mistake again
Gabriel LaBelle, Ella Hunt, Matt Wood, and Dylan O'Brien in Saturday Night (2025)
Live from New York… it's nervous laughter! How Ghostbusters' Jason Reitman nails the all-too-rare dread-inducing comedy with new Saturday Night Live movie
Suzume
The 10 best fantasy movies on Netflix to watch right now
A screenshot of the upcoming TV show Your Friendly Neighborhood Spider-Man, from Marvel's 2024 announcement trailer.
Your Friendly Neighborhood Spider-Man review: "Freeing this creative series from MCU canon is the secret to its success"
Latest in Fantasy Movies
Zoe Saldaña in Avatar
James Cameron's wife cried for four hours after he showed her Avatar 3: "She kept trying to get her s**t back together"
Charli XCX
Charlie XCX is in talks to star in Greta Gerwig’s The Chronicles of Narnia movie - and that is so Brat
Milla Jovovich in In the Lost Lands
Game of Thrones writer George R.R. Martin's In The Lost Lands could get an on-screen sequel, and Martin is apparently keen too
Dave Bautista in In the Lost Lands
Dave Bautista says playing a vampire is "at the top of my list" after starring in Resident Evil director’s werewolf fantasy In the Lost Lands
Sean Astin and Elijah Wood in The Lord of the Rings
Lord of the Rings star Elijah Wood gives unexpected answer on what movie should be removed from cinematic history: "There's nothing pure about it"
Dave Bautista in In the Lost Lands
Dave Bautista says "I always look to Clint Eastwood" when approaching a western role: "He's always going to be my gold standard"
Latest in News
Jack Quaid in Novocaine
The Boys star Jack Quaid's commitment to the bit is unmatched as his latest marketing stunt for upcoming action movie Novocaine goes viral
Daredevil: Born Again
Daredevil: Born Again had Disney Plus' biggest premiere of 2025, but its viewership is lower than Agatha All Along and The Acolyte
Beyond the Ice Palace 2
After 37 years, this Commodore 64 classic returns with a new Metroidvania sequel that gives serious old-school Castlevania vibes
The House of the Dead first look 'Test Subjects'
Resident Evil director offers update on his horror movie adaptation of Until Dawn-sounding video game from over 20 years ago: "It's going to be very, very scary"
True Detective
Matthew McConaughey still thinks his own season of True Detective is the best one: "It was one of the great events in TV"
Diego Luna in Andor season 2
Andor season 2 showrunner Tony Gilroy calls Cassian “Star Wars Jesus” ahead of the show’s return on Disney Plus