If this Anthem player is right, the loot system isn't just bugged - it's fundamentally broken

Poor old Anthem. BioWare’s online open world shooter gracelessly landed into player’s hands less than a month ago, but it already feels like it’s on life support. The developer behind Mass Effect and Dragon Age has been working round the clock to fix the host of technical bugs and balance issues plaguing Anthem and its player base at present, but recent findings from a particularly aggrieved fan suggest the problems run much deeper than the surface level. 

Posting on the Anthem Reddit under the name of TemperHoof, the player goes into great, statistical detail about the hollow correlation between power-scaling, loot, and damage output in the game, showing the mathematical calculations and tests they used to prove their conclusions. It’s so extensive, it’s actually a little bit dry unless you’re really, really invested in Anthem’s under the hood design, but here’s the TL;DR. 

Due to the way Anthem reportedly averages loot out, equipping one Legendary is better than equipping one Legendary and six Masterworks, while Inscriptions (which provide random roll effects on gear) reportedly do next to nothing. This math suggests it's all about your gear's power score and nothing else, and that this has only been exacerbated by update 1.0.3 and its effects on Inscriptions. 

“This isn't some sort of bug”, explains TemperHoof in the post, but “a fundamental design flaw. At this point, the game is lying to you about how much damage you're doing. This is why there is no Stat Sheet, as there isn't anything worth recording. If you play the game thinking your Power Scores, Weapons, Abilities, Components, or the Inscriptions attached to them matter -- then you're doing yourself harm. Follow my advice. Realize that as of 1.0.3, none of it matters anymore and just become Melee & Ultimate spamming gods.”

These underlying problems, which BioWare has yet to comment on, could see the continued drain and aggravation of Anthem’s playerbase, especially since The Division 2 releases today and looks to be a competent offering of all that BioWare - and, to a separate extent, Fallout 76 - have both failed to deliver on. 

The studio did recently respond to the Anthem’s community’s concerns about its lack of transparency since launch, promising that the game “is here to stay” in an open letter on Reddit. We’ll see whether Electronic Arts feels the same way in due course. 

Useless loot isn’t the only snake in BioWare’s boot right now. Check out 11 key Anthem problems that the game needs to fix right away. 

Alex Avard

I'm GamesRadar's Features Writer, which makes me responsible for gracing the internet with as many of my words as possible, including reviews, previews, interviews, and more. Lucky internet! 

Latest in Adventure
an ai chatbot plays a modded verion of pokemon red and jumps down a ledge to talk to an npc
An AI's mission to 'teach' itself Pokemon Red is going as well as you think - after escaping Cerulean City after tens of hours, it went right on back
Pokemon Legends Z-A screenshot showing Mega Charizard
Pokemon Legends Z-A's visuals aren't "great" say former Nintendo marketing leads, but hope Switch 2 could allow Game Freak to "go back to the drawing board" and add more detail to future RPGs
Screenshot of Herdling, showing the weird yaks heading toward a sunset horizon.
With 18,000 glowing Steam reviews on their lovely debut game, this indie team's game about leading cute fantasy yaks up a mountain is instantly one to watch
The two characters in Split Fiction holding their hands up in surrender in a futuristic city
Split Fiction, the new game from the It Takes Two devs, launches to Overwhelmingly Positive reviews on Steam and is the highest rated game on Metacritic this year
Exploring and fighting in Blades of Fire
Blades of Fire plays like a lost Xbox 360-era mashup between God of War and Soulslikes, and it's coming from the studio behind Metroid Dread
Pokemon Legends: Z-A screenshot
Pokemon Legends: Z-A looks to finally bring my anime-inspired dreams of truly active combat to life
Latest in News
Limbo
"You can't rewrite the past just because of a bad breakup": Legendary indie devs' feud is going public
Black Widow
Scarlett Johansson doubles down on never coming back as Black Widow: “Natasha is dead. She is dead. She’s dead. Okay?"
Image of the Blade Runner board game box
Rare Blade Runner board game prototype is being auctioned for over $500 but there’s a far cheaper way to bring the neo-noir classic to your tabletop
Monster Hunter Wilds
Monster Hunter Wilds dev says the game's success is thanks to an "emphasis on the story," but I think that's only a tiny aspect of it
Agricola: Dead Harvest zombie farming board game artwork
Legendary farming board game Agricola just announced a zombie-fueled horror standalone, but fans seem to think it's an early April Fools joke
Lady Gaga as Harley Quinn on set of Joker 2
Lady Gaga jokingly celebrates Joker 2 reception and Razzie nominations: "Joke's on them. I love winning things"