Maybe it's time for Call of Duty to drop the campaign

I love Call of Duty campaigns. Even at their worst, they're still worth a playthrough, as the series tries to explore complex themes while simultaneously offering up mindless Michael Bay-hem spectacle. As profoundly stupid as these games can be, I get the sense that they're often trying to be more than what they are. In between the poor plotting and hamfisted dialog, the recent Black Ops 3 makes an earnest attempt at telling a Phillip K. Dick-inspired nightmare where the the line between man and machine is practically nonexistent. It's not 'art' in the highfalutin sense, and it's not particularly subtle, but it's a lot more than most people give Call of Duty credit for.

But here's the thing: I'm clearly in the minority here. Because as of this writing, only 5.9% of all PS4 players have earned the trophy for finishing Black Ops 3's eight-hour-long story - and that's a significant decline from the 26.3% who completed last year's Advanced Warfare. I'm not sure why the numbers have dipped that low; it could be that more people ended up bailing on its lackluster campaign, or it could be that its co-op nature and lack of level selection restrictions means players are hopping from set-piece to set-piece, without actually 'completing' the game. But even taking Advanced Warfare's numbers into consideration, that's a little under three-quarters of its total players never finishing its six-hour-long campaign. It's enough to make me wonder if the series even needs a campaign anymore.

Activision clearly doesn't seem to think too much of these campaigns, as it's offering a last-gen version of Black Ops 3 for $50, which only includes the multiplayer and a co-op zombies mode. I don't want to be reductive and say that the Black Ops' story is only worth $10, but that's the message the difference in price is sending - that the campaign is the bonus, not the multiplayer. The season passes that Activision offers at an additional $50 a pop don't add anything significant to the single-player experience either, instead filling its already bursting multiplayer option with more maps, modes, and weapons to tide players over until the next yearly release.

There was a time when bundling a campaign along with multiplayer made sense for the series, back when Call of Duty was the young upstart on the block. It had something to prove, and its multiplayer wasn't the guaranteed sell it now is. But with Modern Warfare, the series finally figured out the hook it needed to keep people coming back, combining some of the tightest controls in the first-person shooter genre with a progression system that rewards constant play with a steady stream of unlocks.

The series continues to do exceptionally well, selling millions with each new entry, but as of January 2015, overall sales have been declining since Black Ops 2's release three years ago. And yet, Activision continues to pour money into three different studios, with games featuring three different storylines, all starring big-name Hollywood actors, for campaigns that a fraction of players will ever actually play. I'm all for getting to see some shit blow up in an expertly crafted action set-piece while a dead-eyed Kevin Spacey yells at me, but the quality between campaigns is scattershot - the stellar Advanced Warfare is sandwiched in between the underwhelming Ghosts and Black Ops 3, for instance - and its continued presence feels like a relic of a bygone era, like the only reason Activision continues to make them is because they've always been there.

Unfortunately, people just aren't coming to Call of Duty for that experience. While Larry Hryb (aka Microsoft's Major Nelson) hasn't provided Xbox Live activity data for anything after the week of November 25th, 2013, the stats for that week show four different Call of Duty games in the top ten most played Live titles on Xbox 360. Black Ops 2 is currently the most requested title for Xbox One backwards compatibility. It's clear that people are still playing these games, even years after their release. Considering that the completion percentages haven't really budged all that much, I highly doubt it's to run through the campaign again on a harder difficulty.

I've remarked how fully-priced multiplayer-only titles are a hard sell, but games like Evolve or even Titanfall don't have anywhere near the brand name recognition that Call of Duty does. And sure, they might lose a few sales from people who are only interested in the campaign, but the statistics show that most of the people who play it don't really care about the story - they just want to get to the part where they can mow down their friends as quickly as possible.

There's nothing quite like a hand-crafted Call of Duty roller coaster ride, and I'd certainly miss the campaigns if they weren't there. But I also know that I represent the tiniest fraction of Call of Duty's overall player base, and that the series' yearly schedule helmed by three different studios all but ensures an unpredictable level of quality year after year. Perhaps it's time to drop the pretense that anyone actually cares about these campaigns, and treat the series like what it really is: one hell of a multiplayer shooter.

David Roberts
David Roberts lives in Everett, WA with his wife and two kids. He once had to sell his full copy of EarthBound (complete with box and guide) to some dude in Austria for rent money. And no, he doesn't have an amiibo 'problem', thank you very much.
Latest in Call of Duty
A player wearing a gasmask and holding a gun during the shooter, Call of Duty: Black Ops 6.
Call of Duty season 2 brings back Gun Game and a fan-favorite Zombies weapon we haven't seen in 10 years
A player wearing a gasmask and holding a gun during the shooter, Call of Duty: Black Ops 6.
136,000 Call of Duty accounts have gotten banned since ranked launched for Black Ops 6: "We’re not slowing down in our mission to shut down cheaters"
Call of Duty: Black Ops Cold War
Call of Duty: Black Ops Cold War reportedly surpasses Red Dead Redemption 2's huge development costs, with a massive $700 million budget
Black Ops 6
Call of Duty: Black Ops 6 makes headshots deadlier while cutting back on weapon sway and recoil: "We will be keeping a close eye on sniper balance after this change"
Call of Duty: Black Ops 6 movement.
Black Ops 6 player spent nearly 20 hours grinding to Prestige without getting a single kill, all by spamming Spy Cams
Black Ops 6 Zombies
Call of Duty hacker says "I had my fun" after reportedly getting thousands of Warzone and Modern Warfare 3 players falsely banned
Latest in Features
Patrick Stewart as Professor X in Doctor Strange in the Multiverse of Madness
The classic Fox X-Men are returning in Avengers: Doomsday, and I've got a really bad feeling about this
Thor and Loki in Thor: Ragnarok
After 15 years in the making, Thor and Loki's reunion in Avengers: Doomsday could be the perfect MCU conclusion for the characters
Soft Rains logo with frog drawing
"There is an expectation we're gonna make a little Skyrim": Ubisoft and Bethesda veterans form new studio headed by Skyrim and Fallout designer, debuting with first-person sci-fi and "crunchy mechanics"
Witchbrook screenshot of a library in the magical college with witches flying on brooms
Witchbrook: Everything we know so far about Chucklefish's magical new life sim
The village green in Atomfall
My first 3 hours in Atomfall feel playing Fallout 3 for the first time, and if you don't check it out I'm legally obliged to bash you with a cricket bat
The Demon's Hand
League of Legends' take on Balatro is one of its best mini-games yet – and it's also exactly what's wrong with this era of League of Legends