Nintendo really isn't vibing with the idea of a Legend of Zelda game done in the style of Super Mario Maker.
Speaking to Polygon (thanks, GoNintendo), Zelda series producer Eiji Aonuma explained in some detail why he, and by proxy Nintendo, feels the Zelda series simply doesn't lend itself to the limitless creativity of the Mario Maker series.
"When we’re creating games like Tears of the Kingdom, I think it’s important that we don't make creativity a requirement," Aonuma said. "Instead we put things into the game that encourage people to be creative, and give them the opportunity to be creative, without forcing them to.
- A Zelda movie is finally happening, but Nintendo's Shigeru Miyamoto used to adamantly oppose the idea even "if Steven Spielberg himself" wanted to do it
- Legendary Zelda dev "wasn't too pleased" about working on A Link to the Past as it robbed his enjoyment of playing the finished game: "I still really don't want to play that game"
"There are people who want the ability to create from scratch, but that’s not everyone. But I think everyone delights in the discovery of finding your own way through a game, and that is something we tried to make sure was included in Tears of the Kingdom; there isn’t one right way to play. If you are a creative person, you have the ability to go down that path. But that’s not what you have to do; you’re also able to proceed to the game in many other different ways. And so I don’t think that it would be a good fit for The Legend of Zelda to necessarily require people to build things from scratch and force them to be creative."
In fairness to Nintendo, a Zelda Maker sounds like a whole different beast to Mario Maker. Chiefly, Zelda games don't include the same sort of 2-3 minute self-contained 2D platforming levels that make the classic Mario design such a good fit for a level editor - Zelda dungeons are a lot more complex. It's also hard to imagine how a Zelda Maker would feel like a cohesive experience. Zelda dungeons are often a means to something else; a new mechanic, area of the map, or story development; whereas the whole point of classic Mario is the fast-paced platforming, not to mention co-op multiplayer, which makes the narrative-less experience feel satisfying enough on its own.
Now, a Mario Maker DLC themed around Zelda might just work, but it just feels like there are too many moving parts to translate cleanly into a whole game.
Here are the best Zelda games to play today.
