Skip to main content
Welcome to GamesRADAR+ Community !
Hi ,

Your membership journey starts here.

Keep exploring and earning more as a member.

MY ACCOUNT

Earn your first badge
Read 1 article to unlock your first badge.
Keep earning badges
Explore ways to get more involved as a member.
Latest Games News

Latest Games News

Breaking gaming news and updates

Read Now
Latest Games Reviews

Latest Games Reviews

Expert verdicts on the newest releases

Read Now

See what you’ve unlocked.

Explore your membership benefits.

Explore
Member Exclusives

Stay Ahead with GamesRadar+

Get the biggest gaming news, reviews, and releases straight to your inbox.

Explore
Sign Out
Join The Community
- Join our community
Commenting
Join the discussion
Exclusive Articles
Member-only articles
Weekly Newsletters
Weekly gaming & entertainment news
Member Badges
Earn badges as you go
Exclusive Competitions
Members-only prize draws
Curated Deals Coming Soon
Tech and gaming deals worth grabbing
GET COMMUNITY ACCESS QUICK
For the quickest way to join, simply enter your email below and get access. We will send a confirmation and sign you up to our newsletter to keep you updated on all your gaming news.
By submitting your information you agree to the Terms & Conditions and Privacy Policy and are aged 16 or over.
FIND OUT ABOUT OUR MAGAZINE
Want to subscribe to the magazine? Click the button below to find out more information.
Find out more
GET Community ACCESS QUICK

Join the GamesRadar community for quick access. Enter your email below and we'll send confirmation, and sign you up to our newsletter.

By submitting your information you agree to the Terms & Conditions and Privacy Policy and are aged 16 or over.

GamesRadar+
US EditionUS CA EditionCanada UK EditionUK AU EditionAustralia
Sign in
  • View Profile
  • Sign out
  • Games
    • Game Insights
      • Games News
      • Games Features
      • Games Reviews
      • Games Guides
      • Big in 2026
      • Big Preview
      • Future Games Show
      • Golden Joystick Awards
    • Genres
      • Action Games
      • RPGs
      • Action RPGs
      • Adventure Games
      • Third Person Shooters
      • FPS Games
    • Platforms
      • PS5
      • Xbox Series X
      • PC
      • Nintendo Switch
      • Nintendo Switch 2
      • Tabletop Gaming
    • Franchises
      • Grand Theft Auto
      • Pokemon
      • Assassin's Creed
      • Monster Hunter
      • Fortnite
      • Cyberpunk
      • Red Dead
      • The Elder Scrolls
      • The Sims
  • Entertainment
    • TV Shows
      • TV News
      • TV Reviews
      • Anime Shows
      • Sci-Fi Shows
      • Superhero Shows
      • Animated Shows
      • Marvel TV Shows
      • Star Wars TV Shows
      • DC TV Shows
    • Movies
      • Movie News
      • Movie Reviews
      • Big Screen Spotlight
      • Superhero Movies
      • Action Movies
      • Anime Movies
      • Sci-Fi Movies
      • Horror Movies
      • Marvel Movies
      • DC Movies
    • Streaming
      • Apple TV Plus
      • Disney Plus
      • Netflix
      • HBO
      • Amazon Prime Video
      • Hulu
    • Comics
      • Marvel Comics
      • DC Comics
  • Hardware
    • Insights
      • Hardware News
      • Hardware Reviews
      • Hardware Features
      • Buying Guides
    • Computing
      • Desktop PCs
      • Laptops
      • Handhelds
    • Peripherals
      • Headsets & Headphones
      • TVs & Monitors
      • Gaming Mice
      • Gaming Keyboards
      • Gaming Chairs
      • Speakers & Audio
    • Accessories & Tech
      • Gaming Controllers
      • Tech
      • SSDs & Hard Drives
      • VR
      • Accessories
      • Retro
  • Deals
    • Toys & Collectibles
    • Lego
    • Dungeons and Dragons
    • Merch
  • Video
    • Videos
    • GR+ Replay - Submit Your Clips
    • G+RLS Podcast
  • Edge
  • Newsletters
    • Quizzes
    • About Us
    • How to pitch to us
    • How we score
    • Newsarama
    • Retro Gamer
  • Home
  • Games
    • View Games
      • Games News
      • Games Features
      • Games Reviews
      • Games Guides
      • Big in 2026
      • Big Preview
      • Future Games Show
      • Golden Joystick Awards
      • Action Games
      • RPGs
      • Action RPGs
      • Adventure Games
      • Third Person Shooters
      • FPS Games
    • Platforms
      • View Platforms
      • PS5
      • Xbox Series X
      • PC
      • Nintendo Switch
      • Nintendo Switch 2
      • Tabletop Gaming
      • Grand Theft Auto
      • Pokemon
      • Assassin's Creed
      • Monster Hunter
      • Fortnite
      • Cyberpunk
      • Red Dead
      • The Elder Scrolls
      • The Sims
  • Entertainment
    • View Entertainment
    • TV Shows
      • View TV Shows
      • TV News
      • TV Reviews
      • Anime Shows
      • Sci-Fi Shows
      • Superhero Shows
      • Animated Shows
      • Marvel TV Shows
      • Star Wars TV Shows
      • DC TV Shows
    • Movies
      • View Movies
      • Movie News
      • Movie Reviews
      • Big Screen Spotlight
      • Superhero Movies
      • Action Movies
      • Anime Movies
      • Sci-Fi Movies
      • Horror Movies
      • Marvel Movies
      • DC Movies
    • Streaming
      • View Streaming
      • Apple TV Plus
      • Disney Plus
      • Netflix
      • HBO
      • Amazon Prime Video
      • Hulu
    • Comics
      • View Comics
      • Marvel Comics
      • DC Comics
  • Hardware
    • View Hardware
      • Hardware News
      • Hardware Reviews
      • Hardware Features
      • Buying Guides
      • Desktop PCs
      • Laptops
      • Handhelds
    • Peripherals
      • View Peripherals
      • Headsets & Headphones
      • TVs & Monitors
      • Gaming Mice
      • Gaming Keyboards
      • Gaming Chairs
      • Speakers & Audio
      • Gaming Controllers
      • Tech
      • SSDs & Hard Drives
      • VR
      • Accessories
      • Retro
  • Deals
    • Toys & Collectibles
    • Lego
    • Dungeons and Dragons
    • Merch
  • Video
    • View Video
    • Videos
    • GR+ Replay - Submit Your Clips
    • G+RLS Podcast
  • Edge
  • Newsletters
    • Quizzes
    • About Us
    • How to pitch to us
    • How we score
    • Newsarama
    • Retro Gamer
Trending
  • GTA 6 review
  • Early Black Friday deals
  • GTA 6 News
  • Golden Joystick winners
  • RPG News
  • G+RLS Podcast
  • Submit your clips. Win prizes
  • Deal of the Day
  1. Games
  2. Adventure Games

Sherlock Holmes Chapter One review: "Flawed but nevertheless fascinating"

Reviews
By Rachel Weber
Published 15 November 2021

When you purchase through links on our site, we may earn an affiliate commission. Here’s how it works.

Sherlock Holmes Chapter One review
(Image credit: © Frogwares)

GamesRadar+ Verdict

Sherlock Holmes Chapter One is a flawed but nevertheless fascinating look at the angsty years of the great detective.

Check Amazon
Check Best Buy

Reasons to buy

  • +

    Does detective puzzling like no other series

  • +

    Hot Holmes

Reasons to avoid

  • -

    Problematic like your old uncle at Thanksgiving

  • -

    Budget battles

Best picks for you
  • The best adult board games 2026, from in-depth strategy classics to modern horror favorites
  • I've been running games like D&D for years, and these are the best tabletop RPGs I'd recommend
  • The 12 best board games in 2026, chosen by lifelong fans and industry experts

Why you can trust GamesRadar+ Our experts review games, movies and tech over countless hours, so you can choose the best for you. Find out more about our reviews policy.

 Sherlock Holmes Chapter One is your chance to roleplay as the famous detective, running around the fictional, multicultural island of Cordona as an angst-ridden youngster. You'll solve murders, track down stolen property, fight bandits, and wear more costumes than Lady Gaga on tour. When Chapter One is bad it's really bad, but like the handsome Sherry himself, you can't help forgive it when it gets weird, then flashes you a handsome smile.  

Fast Facts

Sherlock Holmes Chapter One review

(Image credit: Frogwares)

Release Date: November 16
Platform(s): PS5, PS4, Xbox Series X, Xbox One, PC
Developer: Frogwares
Publisher: Frogwares 

 As you'd hope, once you've arrived in Cordona with your mysterious, bossy companion Jon, you barely have time to buy a souvenir fridge magnet before you're working on a case. Cases range from sprawling investigations tied to the main storyline, to smaller mysteries that focus on one location. The best part is absolutely working your way through the bigger cases, using Sherlock's full skill set to do so. Searching the crime scene for every last piece of evidence, dressing in disguises (purchased from various vendors) to win the confidence of sailors, workers, bandits, or vagabonds, and searching the archives of the local paper or city hall for relevant clues. Sherlock can also focus his concentration to see the likely path of a suspect, or do quick chemical analysis (a math-based logic puzzle that - thankfully - you can skip without incurring any sort of penalty) on mysterious substances and observe suspects and witnesses to glean clues from their clothes and demeanor. It's this set of gameplay mechanics that really are what keep people coming back to the Frogwares series, a chance to play pretend from inside the mind of a genius, to feel like a bit of the Sherlock cerebral superpowers have rubbed off on them.  

 Mommy's boy 

Sherlock Holmes Chapter One review

(Image credit: Frogwares)

The real mystery at the heart of the whole game is the root of Sherlock's psychological trauma, one that is slowly revealed through the medium of... shopping. Now, we've hit all headed to Amazon while in the grip of depression and boxed wine, but I did not expect the world's greatest detective to need to purchase a bunch of paintings before he could figure out why he has mental health issues. Sherlock will also encounter different memories as you refurbish the family home, and as you search around Cordona.

At first, Cordona feels a little like an animated screensaver, something you just move past in order to get to the next destination, but the game tries its best to keep you engaged with some side quests later on. A treasure hunt, Sherlock lore, even an overheard conversation that could trigger a case. Don't look too closely at the locals though, because terrifyingly, a lot of them appear to be clones. Perhaps this is a bigger part of a Sherlock-worthy mystery, but I suspect it has more to do with budget constraints. There are also bandit hideaways, which you can enter at any time to try your hand at some fisticuffs. 

 Murder he won't 

Sherlock Holmes

(Image credit: Frogwares)

 These action sequences - which you can trigger with the hideouts or will occasionally happen as part of a case - start out interesting, become tedious, and then sort of circle back to hilarious. You're thrown into a room that serves as an arena with a few objects that can be triggered to deal environmental damage that stuns enemies. Exploding canisters, bags of flour, valves, lamps, the Victorian equivalent of red barrels. Enemies also handily wear accessories that you can shoot at to stun them too, hats, armor, little vials of combustible substances. Stunning an enemy means you can arrest them after a simple QTE punch-up. Crucially, despite being equipped with a gun, you're not supposed to actually kill anyone, and Jon will berate you if you do. When you're shooting off a man's hat while he's moving, it's surprisingly easy to do. The sequences are too easy to clear once you get the hang of them, new enemies are funneled in a few at a time, and they start to drag on. Someone could have budgeted for a few more voice lines for these sequences too, prepare to hear "I will end you" and "I didn't want to miss the party" in indefinable accents at least 237 times. These whole sections could have been scrapped or reduced to just the optional bandit hideouts, and the game would have been better for it.  

 Awkward age 

Sherlock Holmes Chapter One review

(Image credit: Frogwares)

One of the more subjective struggles I had with the game was some of the more nuanced stories it attempts to handle. Despite an early disclaimer about the game being set in different times, there are few cases that hang on characters and twists that feel clumsy rather than capable. When you're racing through a case about a lovelorn, possibly homicidal elephant, you're suddenly hit with an awkward fumbling of issues of gender identity. A search for a controversial stolen painting becomes an investigation into a traumatic sexual assault. Add to that some of the more caricatured portraits of the diverse inhabitants of Cordona and it all just feels a bit old-fashioned, and not in a periodically appropriate way. Tackling difficult subjects in games is a worthy endeavor, but you need to make sure you're doing it right. 

Despite the issues, the moments of cringe, and the occasionally budget feel, developer Frogwares has carved itself a niche delivering Sherlock roleplay to the masses, and this will still scratch your investigative itch. It pulled me in and kept me intrigued - sucker as I am for pretty boys with an air of gothic melodrama about them, and I hope we get to see more of the hot and handsome young Sherlock soon.

Sign up to the GamesRadar+ Newsletter

Weekly digests, tales from the communities you love, and more

By submitting your information you agree to the Terms & Conditions and Privacy Policy and are aged 16 or over.

Sherlock Holmes Chapter One was played on a PS5 with a review code provided by the publisher. 

Sherlock Holmes Chapter One: Price Comparison
View Similar Amazon US
Amazon
No price information
Check Amazon
Best Buy - View Similar
Best Buy
No price information
Check Best Buy
We check over 250 million products every day for the best prices
powered by
GamesRadar
CATEGORIES
PC Gaming Xbox One Xbox Series X PS4 PS5 Platforms Xbox PlayStation
Rachel Weber
Rachel Weber
Social Links Navigation
Contributor

Rachel Weber is the former US Managing Editor of GamesRadar+ and lives in Brooklyn, New York. She joined GamesRadar+ in 2017, revitalizing the news coverage and building new processes and strategies for the US team.

Read more
The Blood of Dawnwalker screenshot
RPGs The Blood of Dawnwalker's lack of stealth makes this Witcher 3-like feel incomplete
 
 
Marvel's Wolverine - close up of Wolverine's face in his game suit with teh cowl up
Action Games Marvel's Wolverine review: "Missing that crucial X-Factor"
 
 
Action Games LA Noire still stands as Rockstar's extravagant, cinematic ode to noir fiction that could have changed everything
 
 
A card, tokens, and miniatures from Unmatched: Cobble & Fog
Board Games This wildly gothic board game pits Dracula against Sherlock Holmes, and it's perfect for fans of both
 
 
Hellraiser Revival screenshot of Chatterer grabbing Aiden in a death animation.
Horror Games Clive Barker's Hellraiser: Revival learned the wrong lesson from Resident Evil 7
 
 
Key art for Silver Pines showing Walker looking upward with the town behind him, one of the lenses in his glasses imposed with 'V' on the jacket of a montaged image of musician Eddie Velvet
Survival Horror Games Silver Pines review: "This Metroidvania take on Silent Hill and Resident Evil is a mystery that's hard to put down"
 
 
Latest in Adventure Games
A Pokemon TCG Flowing Fists Build & Battle Box beside an Elite Trainer Box, on a colorful blurred background
Tabletop Gaming Pokemon cards come out swinging with the next expansion, Flowing Fists
 
 
Protagonist Jordan in a screenshot from the reveal trailer for Intergalactic: The Heretic Prophet.
Adventure Games Intergalactic: The Heretic Prophet is in "the last stages of production," says Neil Druckmann
 
 
Pokemon anime
Pokemon Dumping "up to $2,000" a month into Pokemon fan game, vibe coder says Claude is "starting to refuse"
 
 
A close up of Hope Song's eyes, the hero of Hope in the City
Adventure Games Detective mystery game Hope in the City drops epic launch trailer at the Golden Joystick Awards that's making me reach for my notepad
 
 
A man holds a Pikachu toy, with the same figure displayed in packaging to the right
Toys & Collectibles There's a reason this Pikachu toy took the world by storm in 2026, and now it's 40% off
 
 
Mewgenics
Adventure Games The making of Mewgenics: How Edmund McMillen kept his pet project alive for 13 years
 
 
Latest in Reviews
GTA 6 screenshot
Grand Theft Auto GTA 6 review: "An open world with truly astonishing scale, scope, and quality awaits"
 
 
Geekom A5 2027 mini PC on a wooden desk with blue backlighting
Desktop PCs The Geekom A5 2027 Edition represents solid value for the indie generalist seeking out a compact form factor
 
 
Joseph Zada as Haymitch Abernathy in The Hunger Games: Sunrise on the Reaping
Sci-Fi Movies The Hunger Games: Sunrise On The Reaping review: "A feast to watch that never hits the highs of its predecessors"
 
 
Lego Donkey Kong Arcade beside a Lego NES, Question Mark Block, Piranha Plant, and Metal Gear Solid collectibles as well as Donkey Kong amiibo
Toys & Collectibles Lego Donkey Kong Arcade #72051 review: "I'd go as far to call it one of the best Nintendo sets"
 
 
The Marvel Legendary Second Edition box on a wooden surface
Tabletop Gaming Marvel Legendary 2nd Edition review: "Reboots an already-great card game into something even better"
 
 
Artwork of a dwarf shaman in World of Warcraft: Forever charging up a blue attack in the snow while surrounded by multi-colored flaming torches
World of Warcraft World of Warcraft: Forever review: "A love letter to the MMORPG I fell for over 20 years ago"
 
 
LATEST ARTICLES
  1. You can't tell the story of the multiverse without the God of Stories
    1
    Kevin Feige told Tom Hiddleston that Loki was essential to Avengers: Doomsday
  2. 2
    Clair Obscur: Expedition 33 writer says the games industry "is eating itself" amid layoffs and studio closures – "A lot of what's happening really breaks my heart"
  3. 3
    Hunger Games author Suzanne Collins is "very involved" for "probably hundreds of hours" with the films, says Sunrise on the Reaping director
  4. 4
    Early Lego Black Friday deals live: Tracking all the best offers on Star Wars, Marvel, Pokemon, and more
  5. 5
    GTA 6's shockingly accurate Instagram memes make fun of Rockstar's delays and more as doomscrolling becomes one of the best new activities in the game

GamesRadar+ is part of Future US Inc, an international media group and leading digital publisher. Visit our corporate site.

Add as a preferred source on Google Add as a preferred source on Google
  • About us
  • Contact Future's experts
  • Terms and conditions
  • Privacy policy
  • Cookies policy
  • Advertise with us
  • Review guidelines
  • Write for us
  • Accessibility statement
  • Careers

© Future US, Inc. Full 7th Floor, 130 West 42nd Street, New York, NY 10036.

Please login or signup to comment

Please wait...