Starfield is bigger and more ambitious than Skyrim, but will it stand the test of time in the same way?

Starfield
(Image credit: Bethesda)

On a train journey home from Glasgow city center one wet afternoon in late 2011, I sat opposite a man who'd just purchased Skyrim. Without overly romanticizing the memory, I'll never forget the look on his face as he read the game's description on the back of the box. His eyes were wide and fixated, and he had the faintest of grins as he gripped the plastic on either side of the case with both hands. There was a sense of wonder about his movements as he cracked the seal and unfolded the paper map of the titular realm inside – a behavior I've since observed in my kids while unwrapping birthday presents – before he traced a line between Whiterun and Winterhold with his finger. The scene was so perfect it'd have made a great TV commercial for Bethesda, were it not for the shattered train window covered in bird shit at the man's back, and the fact that the graffitied carriage smelled like piss. 

Fast forward several weeks and, after receiving the fifth mainline Elder Scrolls game myself as a Christmas gift from my girlfriend, I understood the train man's behavior perfectly. That train journey made way for a carriage ride in a similarly decrepit vehicle. In place of the man and I, were the Dragonborn and three other prisoners. Instead of rainy Glasgow, was snowy Skyrim. And that sense of wonder moved from reality to Tamriel. Fast forward 12 years, and players are still discovering that special feeling for the very first time.

In short: an excellent game has been galvanized by a great modding scene, a thriving roleplaying community, and dedicated launches on just about every single platform imaginable – making Skyrim today as legendary as the fable it proclaims. Starfield, on the other hand, is more ambitious than anything Bethesda Game Studios has even created. It's the developer's first new game series in 25 years, and marks a distinct shift in tone away from The Elder Scrolls and Fallout dynasties; swapping fantasy lands and post-apocalyptic planet earth for the near-limitless vast expanse beyond the atmosphere above. 

Starfield has all the ingredients to match Skyrim's legacy, then. So why can't I shake the feeling we won't be talking about it in the same terms as its high-fantasy forerunner down the line?

Spaced out

Starfield character stands in a rocky landscape

(Image credit: Bethesda Softworks)

It's not my intention to be negative for the sake of it here, nor is it my aim to yearn for, or even dwell on, the past. Skyrim is great, but it's also 12 years old. Starfield is great, but it arguably lacks the innovative strides that drove The Elder Scrolls 5 and Fallout 3 forward, in both RPG and open-world sandbox terms. Contrary to Todd Howard's prior claim, Starfield isn't "Skyrim in space" – and while I was unsure if that was a good or bad thing during my first dozen or so hours wandering the virtual cosmos, I'm definitely now leaning closer to the latter the more time I spend among the stars. 

Against its blockbuster sales and impressive player counts so far, I'm not sure Starfield can be described as polarizing per se, but opinion is split among our writers here at GamesRadar+. Our five-star Starfield review bills the sci-fi RPG as the best thing Bethesda has done since Oblivion, whereas Guides Writer Will Sawyer reckons Starfield feels like a missed opportunity for Bethesda to reinvent itself. I myself have definitely been wowed by the vast scale of Starfield, but I probably sit somewhere between these two points of view. Starfield is a brilliant Bethesda game, but, for me, it's not revolutionary in the same way some of the studio's previous outings were. Fallout 3 turned an old-school isometric role-player into a fully blown FPS sandbox extraordinaire, for example, and Skyrim rewrote the rules of RPG high-fantasy, with scores of players using it as an entry point to the Elder Scrolls universe itself.

A dragon blasts a man with a shield in Skyrim

(Image credit: Bethesda)

"But where No Man's Sky's path to improvement was clearly defined from the off, Starfield is under no pressure to evolve in the same manner."

For me, Starfield doesn't possess these seminal qualities. In fact, I'd even argue that Fallout 4 and its multiplayer successor Fallout 76 are less memorable in the pantheon of 21st century Bethesda games, but are elevated by their attachment to their tried and tested series. If we look elsewhere in the sci-fi open-world space, No Man's Sky marks the quintessential iterative journey, whereby the game that launched in 2016 is unrecognizable to the stellar experience that exists today. But where No Man's Sky's path to improvement was clearly defined from the off, Starfield is under no pressure to evolve in the same manner. Updates and DLC will inevitably expand its universe down the line, but the game's early commercial success will almost certainly dictate the pace (or lack thereof) of such a process.

Which is, of course, totally fine. Starfield has a burgeoning modding scene on PC, with roleplay videos steadily filling social media and video sharing sites by the day – in the exact same way Skyrim did at launch. But beyond the honeymoon period of this AAA game; the hype derived from this particular studio and its esteemed back catalog; the console-exclusivity bragging rights that certain facets of players seem eternally obsessed with; and the similar brand loyalty that exists during one of the busiest and most amazing video game release schedules we've had in some time, can Starfield endure with the same stature? I remain unconvinced. 

I've said this before, but Starfield to me is a jack of all trades but a master of none. And, call me a romanticist, but I just can't picture players sharing the same enthusiasm for Starfield's Special Enhanced Anniversary Edition in 10 years time as that man cradling Skyrim in his arms on the train all those years ago.  


Here's a broad selection of the best RPGs you should play right now

Joe Donnelly
Contributor

Joe Donnelly is a sports editor from Glasgow and former features editor at GamesRadar+. A mental health advocate, Joe has written about video games and mental health for The Guardian, New Statesman, VICE, PC Gamer and many more, and believes the interactive nature of video games makes them uniquely placed to educate and inform. His book Checkpoint considers the complex intersections of video games and mental health, and was shortlisted for Scotland's National Book of the Year for non-fiction in 2021. As familiar with the streets of Los Santos as he is the west of Scotland, Joe can often be found living his best and worst lives in GTA Online and its PC role-playing scene.

Read more
Starfield
10 best games like Starfield to get swept up in when you're ready to leave Constellation
Kai and Giatta battle Xaurip in Avowed
I get why Obsidian doesn't like The Elder Scrolls comparisons, but Avowed is the first RPG to have its hooks in me this deep since Skyrim took over my life 14 years ago
Three knights riding on a scenic dirt path in the hills of Bohemia in Kingdom Come: Deliverance 2
"Instant gratification in gaming has become a problem" – Kingdom Come: Deliverance 2 dev says the RPG is meant to feel like a spiritual successor to Oblivion and Morrowind
A massive fireball explosion engulfs Chieftain Grithin in Avowed
In 14 years I couldn't get through Skyrim, but smashed through Avowed in a weekend thanks to its bite-sized exploration and high-impact combat
The Elder Scrolls' Oblivion's most annoying fan holds a torch
Oblivion remake leaks suggest Skyrim's cooler sibling is making a comeback, but I'm worried a modern makeover could bulldoze over the weirdness that makes it great
A trackers alliance agent cocks her head to the side as she tries to entice you to join the organisation
Former Starfield lead says "people are fatigued" with huge games, and "I'm sorry" because "part of what happened is the success of games like Skyrim and Fallout 4"
Latest in Action Rpg
AI Limit
"AI is not as effective as it might appear": Dev of AI-focused Soulslike RPG says they didn't use any AI-generated content and it can't match "genuine creativity"
The First Berserker: Khazan protagonist
The First Berserker: Khazan isn't even out yet, but the new Soulslike RPG already has over 1,300 94% positive reviews on Steam from early buyers
Lies of P art showing P walking in a snowy forest
Lies of P director loves FromSoftware and respects the Soulslike tag, but says "I'm really serious, I'm not lying, I'm very truthful, our focus is to create our own style of game"
Lies of P Overture art of P
Lies of P director says Overture DLC is at least 15 to 20 hours long for "experienced" players, packing tons of bosses and ideas the devs couldn't fit at launch
Monster Hunter Wilds screenshot showing a hunter battling a congalala
If you missed the last one, the new Monster Hunter Wilds event quest is another way to stock up on rare ingredients before the big update drops next week
Monster Hunter Wilds
Monster Hunter Wilds' first major update rights its greatest wrong by adding a proper Palico cooking animation, and it's letting you change Alma's glasses
Latest in Features
Naoe kills a target with a black and white filter over the camera highlighting the red of blood spray in Assassin's Creed Shadows, with an On The Radar orange frame
Assassin's Creed Shadows "has a little bit of Tarantino flavor", but its real secret ingredient is intrigue: "It's almost like you're watching an episode of Shogun"
Helldivers 2 Borderline Justice Warbond helldiver using hoverpack to shoot down with hunting rifle
Talking points from the Game Developers Conference 2025 and how they could impact the future of gaming
Flexispot E7 Plus with plant, monitor, soundbar, and controller on top next to white wall lighting.
Gaming desks vs regular desks: which surface should you buy?
Google Pixel 9a smartphones on a beige background
One Google Pixel 9a feature could make it a better gaming phone than most budget mainstream models
Yasuke and Naoe ready to fight on the Assassin's Creed Shadows On The Radar thumbnail
On The Radar: Assassin's Creed Shadows coverage hub
Alan Ritchson as Jack Reacher in Reacher season 3
Reacher season 3 ending explained: Who dies, does Reacher get his revenge, and how does it set up season 4?