If you want to try tabletop RPGs, I think this one may be better than D&D

The One Ring Starter Set dice in the foreground, with a book and map in the background
(Image credit: Future)

It's generally accepted that one should not delve too greedily or too deep, but there isn't much choice when it comes to the best tabletop RPGs. They tend to draw us in with the stubborn insistence of a black hole, until we're making new characters "for fun" and "just in case I need one, shut up."

So, a couple of questions for you. Have you been bitten by the Lord of the Rings bug after War of the Rohirrim or Rings of Power? Do you enjoy slaying goblins and being a general menace to monsters in RPGs? Have you always been curious about trying games like D&D? Sound the horn of Gondor, because there's a certain roleplaying game you must meet.

Enter The One Ring, or its D&D counterpart, The Lord of the Rings Roleplaying. Developed by Free League (a developer known for excellent tie-ins, from Alien to Blade Runner), these both serve as incredibly authentic but fun windows into Tolkien's world. Actually, the only difference is that LotR Roleplaying uses Dungeons & Dragons rules whilst The One Ring employs its own system.

No matter whether you're new to tabletop RPGs or are used to rolling those bones, I'd argue that they're must-have additions to your shelf.

Lord of the Rings Roleplaying | View at AmazonThe One Ring | View at AmazonBuy it if:Don't buy it if:

Lord of the Rings Roleplaying | View at Amazon
The One Ring |
View at Amazon

No matter whether you want to use Free League's original system (The One Ring) or opt for the D&D version, all the adventures, formatting, and reverence for Tolkien's work is at play here.

Buy it if:
✅ You adore the books and movies
✅ You'd like to get into TTRPGs

Don't buy it if:
❌ You want lots of bombastic action

If you're willing to try something new, I highly recommend picking up The One Ring Starter Set or the core book and an adventure like Moria: Through the Doors of Durin. Although the system may take a bit of getting used to if you usually play D&D, it's very easy to pick up. In addition, I'd say it's a better introduction to tabletop roleplaying in general than Dungeons & Dragons; it's much easier to get your head around, and doesn't make you faff with modifiers nearly so much. In fact, the Starter Set takes place almost exclusively in the Shire and is a delightful yet gentle entry-point for greater adventures. It dovetails nicely into the wider world seen via the main rulebook or various expansions such as Tales from the Lone Lands that thrust you head-first into deeper mysteries.

The One Ring Core Rulebook and dice on a wooden table, against a dark background

(Image credit: Benjamin Abbott)

Meanwhile, the D&D versions simply trade out The One Ring's mechanics for Dungeons & Dragons systems; they're still the same adventures, albeit with different names. That means you can still get in on the action even if your regular group is reluctant to move away from the dragon game.

Well, metaphorically speaking. While combat is obviously included here (and can be rather clever due to positioning or role in The One Ring), it's not necessarily the focus of the game. Rather, it's about journeying across and exploring Middle-earth with your friends, just as it was for the original novels. Yes, you'll be able to stave some orcish heads in. But second breakfasts and elven hideaways are just as important.


For more recommendations, why not check out the best board games? As for last-minute presents, don't miss these gifts for gamers.

TOPICS
Benjamin Abbott
Tabletop & Merch Editor

I've been writing about games in one form or another since 2012, and now manage GamesRadar+'s tabletop gaming and toy coverage. You'll find my grubby paws on everything from board game reviews to the latest Lego news.

Read more
A selection of lifestyle images showing four of the best tabletop RPGs in use
Best tabletop RPGs 2025: Must-have adventures you need to try
An adventuring party points at a tower in the distance
New D&D not piquing your interest? Dragonbane's newest free old-school quickstart adventure will surely sate your appetite instead
Screenshots from the Dolmenwood TRPG
Dolmenwood Review: "A beautifully dark array of narrative seeds waiting to be sewn"
header image for legend in the mist
Legend in the Mist beats Discworld and Dolmenwood in Most Anticipated TTRPGs of 2025 vote
Malediction miniatures on a gray surface in front of dice, with a hand moving one whilst holding cards
Malediction is metal enough to make Elden Ring wince, and I can't wait to play this new wargame
Screenshots from the Legend in the Mist TRPG
D&D is "Great for sh*ts & giggles, but it's so saturated with magic that magic doesn't matter" says Legend in the Mist's lead designer
Latest in Tabletop Gaming
Upcoming support for underground and multi-level dungeons in Dungeon Alchemist
Dungeon Alchemist community manager is "a little concerned how it's behind a paywall to run games" in D&D's official Sigil VTT
Game pieces from Artistry which have an art noveau style
After raising $220,000 on Kickstarter, this art history board game is ready to be the prettiest one in your collection
MTG Final Fantasy art of Kefka Palazzo from Final Fantasy VI dropping potions into water
Following MTG Final Fantasy, another Square Enix Magic collab is “likely a matter of ‘when,’ not ‘if’”
Terraforming Mars TTRPG logo on top art of mars colonists
Terraforming Mars TTRPG crowdfund hits almost $200,000 in one day as fans flock to name a space city after themselves
Ticket to Rde and Catan art side by side
Two legendary essentials for your board game collection are better than half price right now
The White Deer Inn in the Suikoden game
Fans are concerned Critical Role's Suikoden one-shot will be ruined by one player's "complete incompetence and blaming the game"
Latest in Features
Lego Twilight, Easter Egg, Eeyore, and Flowers divided by white lines, with a GamesRadar+ new Lego badge in the middle
New Lego sets in February 2025, from Twilight to Winnie the Pooh
A cropped screenshot from the pre-alpha gameplay footage shown in the 'Introducing Battlefield Labs' video.
Battlefield 6's first teaser takes me back to the days of Modern Warfare 2 lobbies and 24/7 Metro matches, proving we all crave a return to shooters' simpler times
The Invincible War in Invincible season 3
If you think that the Invincible War is over too quickly in Invincible season 3 episode 7, you are missing the point
Lego Star Wars, Mario Kart, Harry Potter, and Marvel kits divided by white lines, with 'New Lego' in a GamesRadar+ badge at the center
New Lego sets in January 2025, from Harry Potter to Star Wars
Infinity Nikki
Infinity Nikki and The Sims' return are only the start of a retro gaming renaissance for Y2K girlies
Avowed screenshot of the godlike envoy with branch-like antlers, pink hair, and mushroom decals framing her eyes. A bow is on her back.
Some of Avowed's most memorable smaller instances are reminding me of the magic of Red Dead Redemption 2's random encounters