The Witcher 3 passes Elden Ring to become the best open-world RPG again

The Witcher 3 next-gen update
(Image credit: CD Projekt Red)

The Witcher 3 has passed Elden Ring and become the best open-world RPG - again. 

The highly anticipated next-gen port of The Witcher 3: Wild Hunt finally arrives tomorrow, letting players relive Geralt's epic adventure with "dozens of visual, performance, and technical enhancements over the original." There are also speedier loading times and a "variety of mods", as well as brand new content inspired by The Witcher Netflix series. 

It's a generous package, even more so given that it's free for anyone who already owns the game. And all those technical tweaks and next-gen polish appear to have paid off for developer CD Projekt Red as currently, The Witcher 3: Wild Hunt – Complete Edition for PS5 is sitting proudly with a score of 97 on Metacritic.

This lofty rating means that it's overtaken the mighty Elden Ring to once again become the best open-world RPG. But CDPR is currently only a gnat's whisker ahead as FromSoftware's latest is on 96. The PS4 and Xbox One versions of The Witcher 3: Wild Hunt, which scored 92 and 91, respectively, were surpassed by Elden Ring when it launched earlier this year. Witcher 3's PC version, which earned a very respectable 93, was also marginally beaten. 

Of course, it's still early days for the next-gen version of The Witcher 3: Wild Hunt and its score could change as more critic reviews get uploaded. Given the level of quality we've seen so far, we don't expect that figure to change much, but there's still a chance that it could dip just enough to allow Elden Ring take back its crown. 

Take a look at our hands-on impressions of The Witcher 3 next-gen update to see what we think of the upgrades so far.

Anne-Marie Ostler
Freelance Writer

Originally from Ireland, I moved to the UK in 2014 to pursue a Games Journalism and PR degree at Staffordshire University. Following that, I've freelanced for GamesMaster, Games TM, Official PlayStation Magazine and, more recently, Play and GamesRadar+. My love of gaming sprang from successfully defeating that first Goomba in Super Mario Bros on the NES. These days, PlayStation is my jam. When not gaming or writing, I can usually be found scouring the internet for anything Tomb Raider related to add to my out of control memorabilia collection.

Read more
Ciri in The Witcher 3
I was terrible at The Witcher 3 until I read the books – now I'm itching for The Witcher 4
Monster Hunter Wilds
Monster Hunter Wilds debuts as the highest-rated game of 2025 with a 90 Metacritic score, and it's the top-selling game on Steam ahead of launch this week
Two Skells flying around a lush green area in Xenoblade Chronicles X: Definitive Edition.
Sci-fi JRPG Xenoblade Chronicles X: Definitive Edition is tied with Kingdom Come: Deliverance 2 as the 3rd highest-rated game of the year on Metacritic so far
Best games like The Witcher 3: Ciri in the Witcher 3
10 Games like The Witcher 3 to play while you wait for The Witcher 4
Kingdom Come: Deliverance 2
Kingdom Come: Deliverance 2 sells 1 million copies in its first 24 hours, and Metacritic clocks it as the highest-rated game of 2025 so far
A sword fight in Kingdom Come: Deliverance 2
Kingdom Come: Deliverance 2 review: "Even if some friction can lead to frustration, its realization of medieval life remains utterly absorbing"
Latest in The Witcher
Witcher comics Geralt
"Something for true collectors": CD Projekt CEO shares his nostalgia for the "super retro" Witcher comics that are coming out in English for the first time
The Witcher 3 lead says "not many games" were trying to match the RPG back in 2015, and that meant "there was a risk" to making it in the first place
The Witcher 4 screenshot with Ciri using sword and sorcery to fight an ancient monster
The Witcher 4 devs explain how Ciri's fighting style will differ from Geralt's: "He's nimble, but he feels like a block...she's liquid"
A screenshot from The Witcher 1, showing Geralt slashing at a hairy beast
Netflix's The Witcher casts its first game-exclusive character with a Witcher 1 deep-cut who Geralt first took care of in the 2007 RPG
The Witcher 3 Geralt
The Witcher series' new book offers a blast to Geralt's teenage past dubbed Crossroads of Ravens, and it'll be out in English this fall
The Witcher 4 screenshot showing the stunning Unreal Engine 5 fidelity
The Witcher 4 director refutes claims that Ciri's appearance has changed since the reveal trailer: "We have not modified it"
Latest in News
Kurt Russell in The Thing holding a stick of dynamite.
43 years later, John Carpenter has hinted at who turns into The Thing in the horror movie and one eagle-eyed fan has worked it out
A WoW Classic player chased by a dinosaur in a green forest
"If this is just how it is, then yeah, that's the end": WoW Classic's most famous hardcore guild calls time for now after multiple raiders lose their MMO characters to DDoS attacks
Megan Fox and Amanda Seyfried in Jennifer's Body
Star of cult hit Jennifer's Body says marketing "ruined" the horror movie's chances, but they may get another shot with a sequel 16 years later
Hollow Knight
Hollow Knight: Silksong gets unprecedented second update in 2 weeks, with a Steam page tweak pointing to a 2025 release
World of Warcraft
My newest MMO hero is World of Warcraft Priest 'Chimneytime,' who got an official "warning" from Blizzard for making too many people get trapped inside chimneys
One Piece
One Piece co-showrunner announces he's stepping away from the "life changing journey" of working on the Netflix show to "focus on myself and my mental health"